Past simple and present perfect.

Sometimes if a webpage is not available Internet Explorer says "Navigation to the webpage was canceled"
Why there is past simple? I think present perfect is more likely.
Navigation to the webpage have been canceled.

For learning: English
Base language: English

171 view(s) since Jul 03, 2009

Is this question related to language learning?

(0)

Answers (2)

Sort by

Best Answer - Chosen by the Asker

The sentence is written in the past simple tense using passive voice.
Navigation to the webpage "was" canceled.

The past simple passive without the use of the word "by" expresses the minimun amount of information about the situation.

By using the simple present passive voice here the idea is that:
-the action happened in the past
-that no action is taking place
-a certain state or situation exists

Using the present perfect passive voice:
Navigation to the webpage "has been" cancelled..

The present perfect passive allows for subtle differences in meaning because it is connected to the "present" tense form of the verb have: "has".

This may indicate that.
-the action happened in an indefinite past up to "now"
-the action is repetitive (perhaps cancelled according to a schedule)
-the action is pending (further action may be taken)

In the simple past passive the past participle functions like an adjective when the word "by" is not used. The situation is static. If there is a specific mention of time then the simple form is used.
Navigation to the webpage was canceled on Wednesday.

In the present perfect the action is more indefinite which is why adverbs like frequently,ever, just,already, still, etc. are often used in the present perfect in order to explain the situation.
Navigation to the webpage has frequently been canceled.
Navigation to the webpage has just been cancelled.
Navigation the the webpage has already been cancelled.

Hope this helps !

:)

Denis answered 4 months ago

Flag

Hello Andrew,
I think you know by now the difference between both tenses .
The past simple tense is concerned with actions that fully terminated in the
past, while the present perfect tense relates to actions taking place in the past
specially the near past and extending in the present and possibly terminating
"just now" in the present.
At the moment when you try navigating a certain website the message you get
indicates that the access to the website is not possible anymore; the action
of navigation was canceled already in the past, prior to you trying to access that
website. It would have been correct to use the present perfect tense if the
cancellation just took place the moment you tried to navigate the website.
It is just like you booked tickets for a certain concert and arriving at time you know
that it "has just been canceled" now. Something occurred suddenly and the show had
to be postponed. Here you use the present perfect tense.
If on the other hand you got a mobile message alert that the show was canceled
3 days previously, but you missed checking it and arrived at the theater you would
hear that the show was canceled 3 days ago.
I hope the difference between using both tenses is clear now with the previous
example.

Cherry answered 4 months ago Flag