Lifelong
The ED endings; asked /t/ or /id/...?

After having studied phnatics, I figured out that (ed) at the end of words has three ways of prounniation:
/t/
/id/
/d/
So, as studies say; (ed) prounced as /t/ if the (ed) preceded by certain sounds, one of them:
/k/ sound.
But once, I've heared the (ed) in a word like (asked) prounnced in two different ways: one time  pronunced /t/, and other time just like /id/!
So is this case just an exception  from the above-mentioned #rule or it has a reason or an explaination?

Thanks in advance!
^_^ 

Sep 4, 2015 12:46 PM
Comments · 9
4

You will hear 'asked' pronounced with a different vowel sound by native speakers from different parts of the world, but never with the /id/ ending. I think you have either misheard or the person you have heard saying this was not a native English speaker. The latter is the likelier option.

September 4, 2015
3

I agree with Jmat. Are you sure that the "ask-ed" pronunciation was from a native speaker? I've only heard it from learners.

September 4, 2015
3

No, this is not an exception. 'Asked' is always pronounced with a /t/ sound at the end. No native speaker would ever pronounce 'asked' as 'askid' in modern English.

Either you misheard, or the person was not a native speaker. Many people whose first language is not English have trouble pronouncing consonant clusters such as /skt/. So even otherwise proficient non-native speakers, such as Spanish-speakers living in the USA, for example, often mispronounce this word and say it as if it were two syllables.

The only verbs where 'ed' is pronounced as /id/ by native speakers are those with base forms ending in the letters 't' or 'd', for example 'wanted' and 'needed'.

 

 

September 4, 2015
2

The general rule is that if the final consonant is voiced, 'd' should be voiced too. If the final consonant is unvoiced, 'd' should be unvoiced (ie. it becomes a 't'). If the final consonant is already a 't' or a 'd', you have to add a vowel before the 'd' indicating the past tense so you can hear the sound e.g. you have to add a vowel between the two ds in 'waded', otherwise it'd sound exactly like 'wade'.

 

I don't think I've ever heard the 'ed' in 'asked' pronounced with an /id/ sound. Are you sure you heard that from a native speaker? It's possible it's just a regional variation I'm not familar with. I know in the southern US they often pronounce 'asked' like 'axed' (the 'ed' is still pronounced as /t/; the difference is that the 's' isn't pronounced before the 'k' and the 'a' is changed to an /æ:/ sound).

September 4, 2015
1

I see what you're getting about the adjective idea. There are certain adjectives that have final syllables pronounced as 'id'. These are the usual ones:

 

Naked

Learned

Rugged

Dogged

Wicked

Wretched

Blessed (sometimes)

Crooked

Beloved (sometimes)

Accursed

Legged (as in three-legged)

 

The only problem with your theory is that, unlike the words in the list above, 'asked' <em>isn't </em>an adjective. It's a verb in the past tense, and as such it is always pronounced as one syllable with a /t/ at the end.

 

If you really did hear 'askid', then it's almost certain the speaker was a non-native.

September 4, 2015
Show more