Marcell Santos
A question

Why is rare to see a comma in english texts? Why it´s not used frequently? In portuguese we use this all the time to separate simple clauses in a complex clauses. But in English I Hardly ever see the comma. Someone tell me why please.

May 21, 2015 5:49 PM
Comments · 14
3

Ok, first of all, nympho?  Auto-correct?

 

I took a course on writing years ago & they pushed the idea of simplifying your writing by removing superfluous commas.  They also suggested that using words like "superfluous" was unnecessary when a word like do.  So I would agree with mempho regarding the sparing use of commas.

May 22, 2015
2

I agree with Dave about editing. Yes, of course that was an auto-correct; you know I'm a no-nonsense kind of poster.

May 23, 2015
2

... "They also suggested that using words like "superfluous" was unnecessary when a word like unnecessary will do."

 

It sure would be nice if this forum allowed edits like every other forum on the net.

May 22, 2015
2

Due to his incredible knowledge of grammar terms (nonrestrictive apposition - holy crap!), I will surrender the point to mempho, and concede the fact that the commas Paul located for you in his first post are optional. That being said, I would definitely put them in myself; I guess it's just personal preference.

 

Now if you look at the first two sentences in Paul's first post, you can see incorrect usage of a commas (sorry Paul). 

 

Peachy is wrong of course. Maybe he meant a clause rather than a sentence? We'll probably never know. But sometimes commas are absolutely required, as nympho pointed out above. 

May 22, 2015
2

It's the same punctuation mark, but we approach it in different ways. In English, a comma is a cut: <em>snip</em>! A perfectly-structured sentence in English doesn't need a comma at all. Commas show that we've needed to chop up the sentence.

I realise other languages use commas to parse and structure the sentence, but it simply doesn't work that way in English. :) It's just different thnking.

May 21, 2015
Show more