Xia
What is it like to live with a solipsist (since this essay is a bit long, I have to publish it in two parts) My roommate always claims that he has a metaphor about the world he lives in, that anybody besides him is an actor. They appear in his life here and there occasionally following the orders of a hidden director. They talk with him and have stories with him without true feelings in their minds. It is him who will always be there and undergo all of these. In fact if you have watched the movie The Truman Show, you will understand what I mean. To him, he is the only true man in the world, and others are all robots, zombies or actors, without souls and consciousnesses. I have asked him about what makes it so important to assume that he lives in a theatre, or why did he treat himself so special. He replied that’s because he is the only one who will never quit the play. In fact he concluded that he would never die, because he is the only audience in this play and without him the world can hardly continue to exist. I commented that he is not the audience but the camera, under which the world can exist. Like what in quantum physics that the state of a particle is determined only when there is an observer. As to him, the whole world is a Schwinger’s cat, and relies on his observation to continue existing. But so what? I can also imagine that other people don’t have minds and they are all NPCs in a giant MMORPG world. However, considering I cannot quit the game until I die, and cannot enter into others’ head, why should I assume that they are all fake and I am real? Even if they are all fake in theory, should I act differently or response differently to them? No. So basically I am an agnostic and I do not care about the “truth”. If other people can pass my Turing test, I have no reason to treat them non-human. So I asked him to imagine that there are two people, one is real in his sense, and the other is an actor(but acts completely the same with real people). Now there is a train coming and each of the guys is standing on different railways and you can determine to which railway the train will reach.(Yes it is like the famous moral dilemma) So which guy will you choose to kill ? He replied, the fake one of course. I smugger sinisterly in heart and kept asking, “ then what if the fake one is a girl you have already fallen in love with, and the real one is just a stranger?” “Well,” He said, “ That depends”
Dec 24, 2014 6:29 AM
Corrections · 4

What is it like to live with a solipsist

(since this essay is a bit long, I have to publish it in two parts)

My roommate always claims that he has a metaphor about the world he lives in, that everybody besides him is an actor. They appear in his life here and there occasionally following the orders of a hidden director. They talk with him and have stories act out scripts with him without havign true feelings in their minds. It is he who will always be is the only real person there and undergo experiencing all of these things. In fact, if you have seen watched the movie <em>The Truman Show</em>, you would understand what I mean. For him, he is the only true person in the world, and others are all everyone else is a robot, zombie or an actors, without soul or consciousness.

I have asked him about what makes it so important to assume that he lives in a theatre, or why did he treat believes himself to be so special. He replied that it is because he is the only one who will never leave the play. In fact he concluded that he will never die, because he is the only audience in this play and without him the world can  not hardly continue to exist. I commented that he is not the audience but the camera, and that the world would still exist without that particular camera. under which the world can exist. Like what As in quantum physics that where the quantum state of a particle is determined only when it is observed. there is an observer. As to For him, the whole world is a Schrödinger’s cat, and it relies on his observation for its continued existence. to continue existing.

But so what? I can also imagine that other people don’t have minds and that they are all NPCs in a giant MMORPG world. However, considering that I cannot quit the game until I die, and that I cannot enter into other people's heads, why should I assume that they are all fake and that I am real? Even if they are all fake in theory, should I act differently or respond differently to them? No. So basically I am an agnostic and I do not care about the “truth." If other people can pass my Turing test, I have no reason to treat them as non-human.

So I asked him to imagine that there are two people, one is real in his sense, and the other is an actor(but acts completely the same as real people). Now there is a train coming and both of them are each of the guys is standing on different tracks. railways and you can determine onto which railway track the train will go. reach.(Yes, it is like the famous moral dilemma.) So which one will you choose to kill? [or better, <em>let die</em>] He replied, "the fake one of course." I snigger sinisterly in heart and kept askied, “Then what if the fake one is a girl that you have already fallen in love with, and the real one is just a stranger?”

“Well,” He said, “That depends”

December 26, 2014
I will correct the minor grammar/syntax errors later, but it seems to me you have not set up the conditions of your moral dilemma adequately. When and how does he learn that one is a "real person" and one is an actor? Has he just learned a few minutes before being presented with the choice that the girl he is in love with is a "fake"?
December 24, 2014
Want to progress faster?
Join this learning community and try out free exercises!