Site Feedback

Resolved questions
Ahi y Aya?? Both mean 'there' but what's the difference?

I seem to understand that both mean over there but what's the rule to know which word when? Help...

For learning: Spanish
Base language: English
Category: Other

Share:

1 comment

    Please enter between 2 and 2000 characters.

     

    Answers

    Sort by:
    Best Answer - Chosen by Voting
    "here" ---> "Aquí", e.g. "¡Aquí esta Juanito (Johnny)! (starts chopping down door with axe)

    "There" ---> "Allí" (if you mean a specific place), "Allá" (if you don't mean an specific place). Sometimes they can be used as synonims without a problem, but "allí" usually indicates more closeness in space than "allá". Also, allá admits distance comparisons, allí doesn't, e.g. "más alla" (more over there), "¿tan allá?" (So far?)

    E.g.:

    Allí:
    1. Dejé el libro sobre la mesa. Busca bien. Está allí. (I left the book over the table. Search carefully. It is there)
    2. ¿Estás allí? (knocking the door: Are you there?)
    3. Dejálo ese allí (put that one there, pointing to the table). El otro déjalo allá (Put the other one over there, pointing to a farther location)
    4. Estaré allí pronto (I'll be over there soon, where the other person is). Voy para allá. (In this case they mean the same)


    Allá:
    1. Állá en Inglaterra está amaneciendo (Over there, in England, it is dawning). In this case using allí would sound awful.
    2. Allá toman más té que aquí (Over there, people drink more tea than here)

    Regards,

    Ahí, es un lugar específico siempre, lo puedes señalar o nombrar.
    Allá es un lugar que siempre es lejano, se usa allá para señalar la distancia más alejada.

    Buenas.
    Veamos en español se suelen usar tres grados para expresar distancias entre personas o cosas. Para eso usamos los demostrativos y los adverbios de lugar.
    Serían: esto/a (aquí o acá) = cercano // eso/a (ahí) = distancia intermedia // aquello/a (allí o allá)
    Espero haberte ayudado.

    Submit your answer


    Please enter between 2 and 2000 characters.

    If you copy this answer from another italki answer page, please state the URL of where you got your answer from.