Site Feedback

Resolved questions
Why 「雨に唄えば」 means "singing in the rain"?

For actions で is used, isn't it? Why doesn't it mean "singing to the rain"?

For learning: Japanese
Base language: English
Category: Language



    Please enter between 2 and 2000 characters.



    Sort by:

    Best Answer - Chosen by Voting
    Today virtually no one speaks in that way, but you may find this usage of 'に' in old movies or books. It is a literary dialect. The 'に' does not mean 'to the rain' but means 'in the rain'.




    The direct translation of "Singing In The Rain" is 雨の中で歌っている/ 唄っている but it's not beautiful nor poetic. When someone translates titles, songs, sentences, books, etc, or write subtitles of the movies, they need to change the meanings to make them beautiful, understandable and natural. So, there are many cases that titles of songs, movies and books are totally changed.

    You are right about your understanding of grammar as far as modern conversational Japanese is concerned. Here the に is used as an attempt to sound poetic and sophisticated and it means "..の中で" or "...という場所で".

    This use of に is not so uncommon in literary language, even now. For example, you could say 沙漠に倒れる and it means something like "perish in the desert" (notice the choice of the word perish rather than die). 光に舞う粒子 is particles dancing in the light. Also, Thomas Mann's novella "Death in Venice" (or Der Tod in Venedig if you will) is known in Japanese as ベニスに死す.

    Submit your answer

    Please enter between 2 and 2000 characters.

    If you copy this answer from another italki answer page, please state the URL of where you got your answer from.