[Deleted]
A listening question in TOEFL. It's confusing- how to tell the implication from what the man said? The man said," There must be something about it (a play), or the professor wouldn't have assigned it". The answer says that we can tell: The man is opsmistic that he will learn to appreciate the play he is currently researching. How to get the implication from his words? It's confusing.
Aug 29, 2015 4:12 PM
Answers · 2
3
The professor assigned the book to the student. Why would a professor assign a bad book or play to a student? We have to believe that he would not assign a bad book or play to a student. The student probably had never heard of this book or play. But the professor recommended it to his student. Therefore, there must be something good or interesting about the play. So, when we read the sentence we understand (it is implied) that the professor believes that there is SOMETHING good/positive/worthwhile about the play, and he also believes that studying the play will benefit the student, and so the professor WANTS the student to read it. In real life, we sometimes say "There is something about that person that I really like." That's a statement of fact, but it implies that the speaker believes that he or she would like to find out if that is true by knowing more about the person that the speaker referred to. The word 'something' often means 'something interesting/good/positive', and less often it can mean or imply something negative. The positive or negative implication depends on what is said before or after the 'something' clause/phrase.
August 30, 2015
3
Hello Shirleen, as the professor has recommended it the man is sure that he will learn something from it. His professor is not likely to recommend something of little value. Bob
August 29, 2015
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!