Recherche parmi différents professeurs en Anglais…
Russia flagMarina
Some dissatisfied things about italki
I think italki is really very popular today. Lots of youtubers from all over the world recommend it in their videos and give the link to it.
But my question is what's wrong with italki? Why not make this site really convenient for people?
I don't like many things about it (how it works) that irritate me every day. I wonder if I am the only one? :))

For example:
1) When I use different networks I always get a sound notification of the messages or when people comment my posts, answer my questions. What is here? Just a little red point as a notification of the messages and NO notification of any comments. So if I'm busy with something else at the moment (working on computer, watching a movie, cooking or anything) I can't know that I have new messages untill I open the page of the site. As for the comments I have to update the page every time to see the number of the comments to my latest posts. And if someone writes any comments to my earlier posts I won't see them at all.
2) It is so inconvenient to read other people's posts! When I am flipping through the feed (I'm not sure if I have used the last phrase correctly) reading the discussions, going down it and suddenly find the discussion that I want to read or participate in, so I open it and read and after that when I what to continue reading the other posts the site brings me back at the very beginning of the feed! I'm always so angry...
3) There is no option to correct the private messages. So if I was writing quickly or just forgot how to write this or that word correctly and after sending the message I found some mistakes in it, I can't already correct them.

Whew, I hope you got my idea and sorry for the possible mistakes in my writing :) Btw, if you can correct me I would be very and very thankful!

Commentaires · 12

8
1_2

Italki is a commercial platform which connects paying users with those selling a particular service, (in this case language tuition / conversation) and – despite the hype – predominantly for English.

Though some posters seem to regard it as a kind of charitable public service, (proof., if needed, of clever marketing - much like this heroically named “Discussion” forum), it is NOT a language exchange facilitator.

Italki is a business that makes its money by taking a 15% commission on paid tuition. – Doesn’t sound much? Just do a rough calculation (15% of - no of lessons per day x number of users x cost per lesson) ….

There are many ways the site could be improved. One for example would be to make it easier to find free language partners. These could include:

  • having a section where new members could introduce themselves

  • a separate dedicated section at the top of this page where one could search for partners (instead of hiding it away under “community"

  • a search function that doesn’t immediately reset to default whenever you click on any one individual profile

  • a live section listing those currently available for spontaneous (free) conversation or tuition

  • an algorithm that would use clear and structured user profiles to match a search entry with compatible partners

  • etc. etc. etc. ….
7
2_2

But …. since these would all impact on the current - and highly lucrative - business model, why bother?
The facility to ostensibly “search” for a partner (however ineffectually) also makes complete sense, again as a marketing ploy, rather like those “FREE” offers to entice you into a store where you find much more tempting things to spend your cash on.    

There are alternatives. Verbling, Preply and First Tutors are some, Conversation Exchange is another one, though with a somewhat different approach.

Here the idea is that users post their profiles and search for someone speaking their target language in their local area, with whom they can, if they so wish, meet up in person for a free exchange.

For obvious reasons, this has had very limited success and in turn a low take-up compared to commercial platforms like italki. That is not to say, however, that you might find someone there and choose to communicate with them just using Skype or email, regardless of where they happen to be.
If anyone has tried this or similar platforms (like those mentioned), maybe they would like to comment on their experiences. 

There are many language learning apps now available, many of them free (or with a downscaled free version): Clozemaster, Memrise, Busuu, Yabla, Duolingo and so on, but these all offer different approaches to enhance language learning. While they might represent useful additions to the italki program none of them could be considered alternatives or a serious challenge to italki’s current market position.
2
For 2:
use the keyboard shortcut CTRL+ left-click the link you want to open. This will open that link in a different tab in the browser, and so you won't lose the current page. Use it a couple times and muscle memory will do the rest.
1
Sure Som! No problem :)
1
Marina, may I quote your this post in a post that I'm thinking of writing?

Ne manquez pas cette occasion d'apprendre une langue depuis chez vous. Découvrez notre sélection de professeurs de langues expérimentés et inscrivez-vous dès maintenant à votre premier cours !

Commencez à apprendre aujourd'hui