Why do I find grammar rather useless when studying a target language?
When talking in their target language, everyone has to think of the correct words to say. However, in our mother tongue we do not feel such a need. Why? Well, you learned your mother tongue by both listening to others (input) and speaking the things you heard (output). What is more, you learned it without paying attention to grammar and, as a result, you would be able to spot any mistake in any sentence, not because you know by heart all the grammar rules of your language, but because you "feel" it. This tells us the role of grammar when it comes to really speaking a language. You do not make use of it when speaking in your mother tongue. Because of that, grammar rules are only useful when it comes to passing an exam, in which you fill gaps. So, when learning your target language, focus on the input: do read a lot, listen to recordings, and write down every piece of useful vocabulary. As a result you will have whole heaps of new words and expressions. This is not to say that you do not have to study grammar, but you may shrink the time you spend on it. To my mind, this is the way forward.
Recherche parmi différents professeurs en Anglais…
Corrections · 2
0
I personally value the role that grammar plays in a language.
Firstly, it is a handy way to speed up the learning curve. If you are exposed to a lot of Spanish or spend a lot of time listen/watching Spanish, yes, you will eventually learn the patterns through deduction. (This, by the way, is also an academic strategy of teaching grammar.) I personally prefer being presented with the rule beforehand so I can make sense of it in my head and then consciously notice the application of it in everyday life or when reading, listening and watching (as you suggested).
Also, some grammar rules are simple enough that I only need to be told once and I will forever remember. Example: In Spanish, the adjective comes after the noun. Done. Now I know.
Of course, the most important part of this is application and practice because, as you pointed out, it is a lot harder and slower to constantly be calculating grammar formulas in your head before speaking. But, if you practice the learnt rule very often, it will in time become instinctive.
Secondly, it is important if you want to have an academic level of the language you are learning, which includes a good level of writing. There are different levels of English within the masses of native speakers. Just because it is your native language and you can communicate perfectly using it, it does not mean you have a high level of it. There are tons of native speakers who, everyday, use the wrong forms of
"to, too and two"
"their and there"
"lend and borrow"
... the list goes on.
But sure, they can express themselves and they will never know the difference. Although, when writing a cover letter for a job interview and stating: "I wood like to work their because...", I doubt they would get the job.
So I guess it depends on why you are learning a language and what kind of level you would like to have.
0
Why do I find grammar rather useless when studying a target language?
When talking in their target language, everyone has to think of the correct words to say. However, in our mother tongue we do not feel such a need. Why? Well, you learned your mother tongue by both listening to others (input) and speaking the things you heard (output). Furthermore, you learned it without paying attention to grammar and, as a result, you would be able to spot any mistake in any sentence, not because you know by heart all the grammar rules of your language, but because you "feel" it. This tells us the role of grammar when it comes to really speaking a language. You do not make use of it when speaking in your mother tongue. Because of that, grammar rules are only useful when it comes to passing an exam, in which you fill in gaps. So, when learning your target language, focus on the input: do read a lot, listen to recordings, and write down every piece of useful vocabulary. As a result, you will have whole heaps of new words and expressions. This is not to say that you do not have to study grammar, but you may lessen the time you spend on it. In my mind, this is the way forward.Vous souhaitez progresser plus vite ?
Rejoignez cette communauté d'apprentissage et essayez les exercices gratuits !
Ne manquez pas cette occasion d'apprendre une langue depuis chez vous. Découvrez notre sélection de professeurs de langues expérimentés et inscrivez-vous dès maintenant à votre premier cours !
Commencez à apprendre aujourd'hui
