Ehsan
any + singular countable nouns? Are both a and b correct? a. are there any differences? b. is there any difference? any + singular countable nouns
8 févr. 2016 18:53
Réponses · 7
2
Both are right. But in (b) the noun 'difference' is used as an uncountable noun, rather than a singular countable noun. You are right in thinking that you cannot use 'any' with this meaning before a singular countable noun in a question of this type. The singular countable version of this question would be 'Is there a difference?'. When we say 'Is there any difference?' we are treating the word 'difference' as an abstract concept, so it is therefore uncountable. The answer might be 'No, there isn't much difference' or 'No, there is very little difference' or 'Yes, there is a great deal of difference'. As you can see from the use of the singular verb and the quantifiers 'much', 'many' and 'little', we are dealing with an uncountable noun here. It is quite common to have two versions of the same sentence, one with 'Are there any ...?' and one with 'Is there any...?', where the second is an uncountable and more 'abstract' version of the first. Similar examples are: Are there any benefits? Is there any benefit? Are there any advantages? Is there any advantage? I hope that helps.
8 février 2016
1
I think in (b) you are treating "difference" as an uncountable noun. The word can be used thus, and that becomes clear if you consider a variant of your example, "Is there much difference?"
8 février 2016
1
yes
8 février 2016
Vous n'avez pas encore trouvé vos réponses ?
Écrivez vos questions et profitez de l'aide des locuteurs natifs !