Recherche parmi différents professeurs en Anglais…
Viktoriya
Is this dialogue correct?
- Somebody is swimming.
- Who is swimming?
- A man and a woman.
I and my daughter were near a swimming pool and there were two people in the water. My daughter said: somebody is swimming. But there were two people in the pool! Should I ask her "who are swimming?" in this situation?
Thank you for your help!
24 oct. 2017 12:16
Réponses · 4
1
Since your daughter said, "(Somebody) is swimming." it is grammatically correct to say, "Who is swimming?" in response since the phrasing makes it seem like only one person (singular) is involved.
If she had said, "Some (people) are swimming." (plural) then that would be the right time to ask, "Who are swimming?".
24 octobre 2017
1
In American English, "who is swimming" is standard.
I believe this might differ by country though; one of the differences between British and American English is the choice of verb conjugation in certain situations, and I'm not entirely sure where all the differences come up. For example, American: "Boston *is* playing New York (in a baseball game)," but British: "Tottenham *are* playing Arsenal (in a football match)."
24 octobre 2017
Of course u could ask in that way u tryying to do.
- Somebody is swimming.
- Who is swimming?
- A man or a woman.
My daughter and I were near to a swimming pool and there were two people in the water. My daughter said: somebodies are swimming. But there were two people in the pool! Should I ask her "who are swimming?" in this situation?
Thank you for your help!
24 octobre 2017
Vous n'avez pas encore trouvé vos réponses ?
Écrivez vos questions et profitez de l'aide des locuteurs natifs !
Viktoriya
Compétences linguistiques
Anglais, Allemand, Italien, Russe, Ukrainien
Langue étudiée
Anglais, Allemand, Italien
Articles qui pourraient te plaire

How to Ask for a Raise or Promotion in English
9 j'aime · 8 Commentaires

The Key to Learning a Language Faster
30 j'aime · 8 Commentaires

Why "General English" is Failing Your Career (An Engineer’s Perspective)
30 j'aime · 12 Commentaires
Plus d'articles
