Maria Clara
WHEN SHOULD I USE SHALL? When should I use shall? Does it have the same meaning as will? I have seen some videos about the uses of shall but I'm still confused. Is it something extremely important for my study? 
2016年5月29日 00:10
コメント · 5
4

Shall and will are different, and you need to know how to use both.  If you are using textbooks in a course, you'll be taught the difference around pre-intermediate level.  Yes, this means it is important.

We typically use shall for offers and suggestions in question form, and when you use I and we.

Shall I open the window?

Shall we go out for dinner?

It is not possible to use will and keep the same meaning.  "Will I open the window?" means you don't really know!  So, you can start practising your Shall I...? and Shall we...? phrases right now. :)


If you get to upper-intermediate level, you'll see how shall is used for serious obligations. The word shall is often found in legal contracts.

There's no difference between US and UK English here. It's a standard usage.

2016年5月29日
3
Depends. Is your audience American or English?  Americans seldom use shall these days.  If you are writing something formal 'shall' is ok, but if not 'will' sounds more natural to us. 
2016年5月29日
2

Here's a handy guide for these modals... it's not a proper definition, but it gives you the idea behind each modal:

will -> volition

shall -> obligation

Must has the sense of obligation/motivation, but the origin is a little more difficult to describe. Anyway, knowing how shall works can explain the different uses of should (I mean, its uses aside from advice).

2016年5月29日
2
Shall has the same meaning as will, but it is considered to be very formal and archaic, so most people don't use it in regular conversation. I hope that helps! 
2016年5月29日
I used to face "shall" when I was reading a list of Technical requirements from official papers. It was like "The system shall have the next parameters..." And I noticed to myself that in technical English "shall" might be equal to "must". Am I right? Or it's just technical style to write in future tense?
2016年5月29日