xiaokaoy
Is a comma necessary? My daughter, Jane, never... Can I say "My daughter Jane never..."?
2012年11月21日 03:25
回答 · 6
1
I looked this up in a punctuation style guide and here's the rule that might be pertinent... Unless a comma is required to prevent misreading, you may omit it in short, closely related clauses. So, no comma required.
2012年11月21日
The comma in this case is completely unnecessary and it is recommended not to use it. "My daughter Jane never ..." is fine. You only use the comma in such situations when you really want someone to read the sentence with pauses where commas appear. e.g. "My daughter, Jane, never went to school" will be read with pauses after Daughter and Jane.
2012年11月21日
No, the comma isn't necessary. You can say, "My daughter Jane never got married." Or things similar to that. I think your example with the comma is attempting to slow the words down to the reader for effect.
2012年11月21日
まだあなたの答えが見つかりませんか?
質問を書き留めて、ネイティブスピーカーに手伝ってもらいましょう!