Weiyang Luo
if that be...Grammatically correct? If that be error and upon me proved,I never writ,nor no man ever loved.----sonnet 116 If that be the case,you'll be dining with the crew,and you will be naked.----Pirates of the caribeans In what situations can ''be' be used in place of "is "or "are"?(be in place of is or are I mean"be" is not after"to","should"ect,but in an"if sentence.").
2013年6月21日 00:39
回答 · 6
2
Sonnet 116 isn't English, it's Old English. Most English speakers either can't understand what Shakespeare wrote, or they do so with great difficulty. I'm struggling to figure out what that sentence means. "If that be the case..." isn't correct English, but it sounds good when spoken with a pirate accent (which is why pirates speak like that in fiction). Both instances of "You'll be..." work like normal English.
2013年6月21日
2
It is actually heard . from time in American English to express the possibility of a situation to exist. It's the present subjunctive and it's correct, but not common. "There might not be beer at the party." Well, if that be the case, I might as well stay at home.". A situation that may or may not exist.
2013年6月21日
2
It is literary English. You won't need it for modern English.
2013年6月21日
1
"IF THAT BE so, I shall have my head examined" the judge ridiculed at the prosecution's far fetched scenario. It's correct English. It depends on the class of people you are talking to, the educated or the not so.
2013年6月21日
Mojave made a good comment above: it's the present simple subjunctive. In both of your contexts, the speakers (a poet and a pirate! yarrr) use this form more freely than an average modern English speaker would. Still, it's perfectly correct grammar. Basically: "I am / we,you,they are / he,she,it is" = indicative mood, ie. it exists in reality. However, "(subject) be..." = subjunctive mood, ie. it exists in theory. A modern speaker would prefer "If that is" over "if that be", but both are grammatically correct.
2013年6月21日
まだあなたの答えが見つかりませんか?
質問を書き留めて、ネイティブスピーカーに手伝ってもらいましょう!