多彩な 英語 講師陣から検索…
Flor Astorga
Wich Is correct?
"The doctor WON´T have had a chance to look at your X-ray yet."
OR
"The doctor MAY NOT have had a chance to look at your X-ray yet."
2014年7月15日 17:23
回答 · 9
6
Both are correct. The second one implies that there is a possibilty that the doctor will be able to check the X-rays, while the first does not.
2014年7月15日
6
As Matt has said, they are both correct. Believe me - your grammar is fine.
There is a difference in meaning, however.
"The doctor WON'T have had a chance to look at your X-ray yet' suggests that the speaker is sure that the doctor hasn't seen it yet.
"The doctor MAY NOT have had a chance to look at your X-ray yet." suggests that thinks that it's possible that the doctor hasn't seen it yet.
2014年7月15日
2
First sentence is incorrect. As far as I know the Future Perfect is used only when there is a sequence of tenses. But your example doesn't contain it. Maybe the others sentences in the text contain it but I'm not able to know it.
2014年7月15日
1
Well first of all, you spelled which wrong. WHICH IS CORRECT
THE DOCTOR WON'T HAVE A CHANCE TO LOOK AT YOUR X-RAY. Don't put "have had." That is the correct way. Indicating that the doctor will not look at the x-ray at all or never.
THE DOCTOR MAY NOT HAVE A CHANCE TO LOOK AT YOUR X-RAY YET. Again don't put "have had" This is the correct way. Meaning the doctor will look at your x-ray, but not now.
The most correct one is: The doctor may not have the chance to look at your x-ray yet.
2014年7月15日
Right, both are correct but the sentences have different meanings.
2014年7月19日
さらに表示
まだあなたの答えが見つかりませんか?
質問を書き留めて、ネイティブスピーカーに手伝ってもらいましょう!


