Ken Hennessy
Is it ok to skip learn grammar first? Bonjour à tous. I have been learning French with the Benny Lewis Fi3M program. I am still finding it hard to get a decent conversation going. I can remember words ok but I can't seem to structure a sentences properly. Could this be because a lack of grammar? Or just lack of practice? Any advice on getting my sentences more refined? Merci beaucoup!
2017年9月29日 00:27
回答 · 2
3
PART 2 of 2 The first reason English speakers can’t automatically understand French is that the pronunciation is radically different, so that should be a high priority. This doesn’t take that long to handle — you don’t have to have a perfect accent, you just have to master a couple of dozen phonemes and some stress and intonation patterns. Definitely get a handle on the phonology, before memorizing thousands of words with terrible pronunciation. The second reason is the grammar. Again, you’ll want to practice using it under controlled conditions, rather than inventing your own language. It’s a lot quicker to learn something right once, and then practice it, rather than learning it wrong, practicing it wrong, unlearning the wrong way, and then learning it right. I wish you good luck in your French learning adventure!
2017年9月29日
3
PART 1 of 2 It’s very motivating to start using the language right away, but yes, you’ll want to learn the basic grammar (i.e., how to put words into a sentence) ASAP. Otherwise, every time you speak, you’ll be practicing bad French. The fact is, over a quarter of English words are from French, and an additional number of English words (more than 50% total) are directly from Latin (the mother language of French). This is why learning vocabulary should not be the focus for a native English speaker learning French. Of course, there are a few hundred very common words that are different, and absolutely need to be learned. Guess what — most of these super common words are actually structural — i.e. grammar. You cannot just learn “le” means “the” — you need to know exactly when to use which article (gender, number, definite, indefinite, partitive…). We cannot just learn that “to be” is “être” that will never work. It’s not 100% necessary to know the terminology (although it’s easy enough to pick up, and can save lots of time in the long run), but you do need to practice using grammar to express your ideas (out loud, in real time), rather than just floundering around during a conversation. This will also help with your listening. What makes English and French different is principally the grammar, as well as the pronunciation. Almost all of the content words in the last sentence are the same in French: Anglais, français, différents, principalement, grammaire, prononciation.
2017年9月29日
まだあなたの答えが見つかりませんか?
質問を書き留めて、ネイティブスピーカーに手伝ってもらいましょう!