Hamid
Which one is correct? 1. Who is swimming?

2. Who are swimming?

I was in class when one of the students asked teacher; who are swimming? (Pointed to a picture that two people were swimming) and the teacher corrected him and said "who is".

Why do we say "who is" even when we see two people in the picture?

Thanks in advance.

2018年6月14日 10:00
回答 · 5
1
The verb form does not relate to the number of people you can see - it relates to the interrogative pronoun WHO, which is a singular noun. Whether there are two people or two hundred people swimming is irrelevant. 'Who' is singular, so the verb has to be singular to agree with it. Note that 'what' is also singular. 'Who is living in that house?' Mr and Mrs Brown 'What is in the basket?' Apples, pears and bananas.
2018年6月14日
i think you should ask ur teacher whenever u're confused but anyway, i think if you want to ask about people who are swimming, the question could be that who are swimmers? swimming is a noun, so i guess ur teacher uses it as a noun in this question "who is swimming". Furthermore, I've never seen any questions like "Who are swimming?"Even when i rewrite, it seems weird to me
2018年6月14日
まだあなたの答えが見つかりませんか?
質問を書き留めて、ネイティブスピーカーに手伝ってもらいましょう!