Emory
[ Grammar ] With + Object + Complement ( Ving/ Vpp ) vs Absolute phrase Sentence 1 : With + Object + Complement ( Vpp = past participle.) Jim hugged me with his head tilted toward me as we watched TV. Sentence 2 : Absolute phrase Jim hugged me, his head tilted toward me as we watched TV. Sentence 3 : With + Object + Complement ( Ving = present participle.) With his head tilting toward me, he showed that he was sorry for what he said. -------------------------- Question 1 : Is “ tilted ” regarded as adjective rather than passive voice in Sentence 1 ? Question 2 : Is there any difference of meaning between Sentence 1 and 2 ? Question 3 : How do we distinguish “ tilted ”and “ tilting ” ? Could we use “ with his head tilting ” in sentence 1 ? and use “ with his head tilted ” in sentence 2 ? ------------------------ Thank you very much : )
2019年4月10日 13:56
回答 · 3
1
1 - tilted can be a verb or an adjective, but it's a verb in this case due to its position in the sentence. 2 - No, they have the same meaning. 3 - tilted is used in the past in a passive sentence, tilting is used in an active sentence. This is the reason 'head tilting' is incorrect, because the head is passive. With his head tilted in sentence would be correct, as well.
2019年4月10日
まだあなたの答えが見つかりませんか?
質問を書き留めて、ネイティブスピーカーに手伝ってもらいましょう!