Sasha
プロの講師
Gerund as a Subject (There's no doing smth) Hello! Are these sentences ok to give an example of a gerund in the meaning of a subject in this structure (There is/was no + doing something)? 1. There's no talking to her when she is in such a mood. 2. There is no stopping them now. 3. There was no denying it. Could you write one common example to add? Thank you!
2020年5月18日 11:56
回答 · 5
1
The gerunds in those sentences are not subjects. In those structures, they are just nouns. It's the same as saying 'there's no rice in the cupboard'. An example of a gerund as a subject could be 'Smoking is bad for you.' or 'Swearing doesn't help anybody'. Is it that by 'subject' you mean 'noun'? As David says, the sentences are all correct.
2020年5月18日
"There's no pleasing him" - great example. Thank you!
2020年5月18日
All three sound correct and are commonly used. As to whether they are grammatically correct or are examples of colloquial speech, maybe one of the English language experts can comment. Another example would be "there's no pleasing him", meaning whatever you do or say, he'll never be satisfied.
2020年5月18日
まだあなたの答えが見つかりませんか?
質問を書き留めて、ネイティブスピーカーに手伝ってもらいましょう!