Clair
Someone can explain me the difference in meaning between these two sentences? 1- He’s gone to the beach 2- he’s been to the beach
2023년 12월 12일 오전 10:32
답변 · 4
4
Hi! So he’s gone to the beach implies that he went to the beach earlier and is still there. You could reply with this if someone asked: where is he? He’s gone to the beach. He’s been to the beach means he was at the beach sometime in the past but is not there anymore at the moment of speaking. For example: he’s been at the beach many times before. Hope this helps:)
2023년 12월 12일
#1 says he has "going to the beach" as an experience. This means at some time in his lifetime he started to travel with the beach as his destination. It does not mean that he necessarily ever arrived there. It does not mean that he necessarily is there now. He might still be on his way to the beach, or he might not. However, with additional context it could imply such things. For example, from this conversation it can be reasonably guessed that he is at the beach right now: Question: Where is Jack? Answer: He's gone to the beach. #2 says he has "being at the beach" as an experience. This means that at some time in his lifetime, he was at the beach. It gives no information about whether or not he is there right now. It just means that the beach is one of the places where he has been during his lifetime. Additional context would be needed to know if he is there now or not.
2023년 12월 12일
1. "He's gone to the beach" means he's at the beach right now. 2. "He's been to the beach" means sometime in the past he was at the beach. BUT if you add "before", "in the past" to the end of the first sentence- "He's gone to the beach before" means the same thing as "he's been to the beach".
2023년 12월 12일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!