绑德sings
Hello native English speakers. American ticket sales the first weekend it was released made "New Moon" the third best-selling movie on record. (original) Question: Is the original grammatically correct? What does the pronoun "it" here refer to? I guess the "it" does not refer to the "first weekend" with its meaning depending on the context of the original. I boldly guess the "it" here refers to the name of the film "New Moon" ,but I have no confidence to decide whether or not correct my guess is.
2024년 5월 7일 오후 2:38
답변 · 7
3
It's grammatically correct. The it does refer to New Moon - the actual film, not it's name. Because whatever 'it' is 'was released', it must mean the movie as this is the only thing in the sentence that can be released. You could add a few words to make it easier to understand: American ticket sales [for] the first weekend [that] it was released made "New Moon" the third best-selling movie on record. You could also swap the pronoun and the noun: American ticket sales the first weekend "New Moon" was released made it the third best-selling movie on record. The original version sounds better, though, as it keeps the title closer to the important thing we want to say about it.
2024년 5월 7일
2
I assume that the movie had already been mentioned in a previous sentence. If that's true, then "it" is referring to the film. If the film hadn't been mentioned in a previous sentence (which I doubt is the case), then "it" would be a pronoun that didn't have an antecedent- which would be an error.
2024년 5월 7일
1
Yes, "it" refers to the film. Your sentence would be better with a preposition to connect "ticket sales" to "the first weekend". There are several prepositions that would work well: "ticket sales during the first weekend" "ticket sales for the first weekend" "ticket sales on the first weekend" "ticket sales over the first weekend" It is permissible to omit the preposition but the sentence is clearer if you use one.
2024년 5월 7일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!