다양한 영어 선생님을 검색해 보세요...
Hong Kong SAR China flagJoy
Fair: Majority or Minority This is a public class: http://www.tudou.com/programs/view/y4u_ovHcZLU/?resourceId=0_06_02_99 At first, the professor introduced utilitarian morality raised by Banthem, which is, the highest principle of morality, personally and politically, is to maximise the general welfare or the collective happiness, or the overall balance of pleasuer over pain. In the following discussions, some students argued that "this principle doesn't respect individual or minority rights", while Banthem‘s supporters refuted that the minority’s rights had already been considered, but "people have to make a decision". Another objection was that some students insisted that "it is not possible to aggregate all values to translate them into dollar terms." In my opinion, the essential factor of the difference between minority and majority is not the number, but the power. More precisely, so many people believe that it is more fair to give priority to the majority, just because they believe what they are living in now is not a hierarchical society, which is withe the emerging of the concept of equality. Since every individual's power is equal to each other, the number becomes a practical way to measure the power. On the opposite, in a hierarchical society, the enactment of legislation is just to maximise the benefits of the minority, because they control the biggest social power. From this perspective, there is no absolute fair. Fair is just the result of a game. No one deserves privilege naturally. The very reason that why the majority care about the minority's rights is not only because of the kindness, but becuase this distribution is not set. One good strategy of the weak minority to ask more support from the majority, is let them feel that they might become one of them. In the case showed in the class, which was about an investigation about smoking, citizens were so angry even though they could earn more money if the cigarettes were not controled strictly by the government, is not because this investigation was "heartless", but because the people who smoked were not set. That is to say, any of them could be the victim. Hence, the best goal to make policy principles is neither for the majority alone nor the minority, but to find a balance or compromise between them.

교정 · 0

집에서 편안하게 언어를 배울 수 있는 기회를 놓치지 마세요. 경험 많은 강사진을 살펴보고 지금 바로 첫 수업을 신청하세요!

오늘 학습 시작하기