다양한 영어 선생님을 검색해 보세요...
Costa Rica flagJheison
You and I or you and me? I have recently seen that many people use a pronoun and I. But in my mind I have that the correct form is using me instead of I. Could anybody help me with this doubt?

교정 · 5

0
Jheison. Yes, in your specific example you would say, "In this discussion, just you and I are the participants." Kiri and I suggested the same way of testing to see if "I" or "me" is correct -- drop the other subject and try the sentence with only I/me. So, for your example sentence, one option for saying it without the "you" would have been, "In this discussion, just me am the participant." (hmmm...that doesn't sound right..."just me is the participant"? No, that doesn't sound right, either. hmmm....I can't make the sentence sound right with "me"). The other option without the "you" would have been, "In this discussion, just I am the participant." (OK, the grammar sounds fine there. I might normally choose a different way to phrase the idea...perhaps "I will be the only participant." But it is only a test sentence and I recognize that the grammar is correct with "just I am the participant"). So, that tells me that the correct choice is to use "I" in the sentence "In this discussion, just you and I are the participants." ~~~~~~ I hope this explanation has been helpful.
0
Fantastic, now I am very clear. Thank you so much!
0
It depends. Use "You and I" if they are subject pronouns in the sentence ( "You and I saw the same movie this weekend." "You and I have been friends for five years." ) Use "You and me" when they are object pronouns in a sentence ("He is giving these books to you and me." "Writing this essay will be difficult for you and me.")..............In some sentences, it can be a little harder to decide whether to use "I" or "me" -- and, to be honest, it is pretty common for native English speakers to make mistakes. A simple test that helps choose the correct pronoun is to try saying the sentence with only the "I" or "me" and see which sounds correct (would I say, "I saw the movie" or "Me saw the movie?" Definitely "I." Would I say, "Writing this essay will be difficult for I" or "Writing this essay will be difficult for me?" Definitely "me".)
0
haha thanks a lot. Just for clarifying, in this example: In this discussion just you and me are the participants. Or: In this ... you and I ... ?
0
It depends on the sentence. For example, in a sentence you'd normally start with 'I' if it was only you in it would be 'you and I' whereas a sentence wouldn't usually start with 'me'. e.g (you and) I went to the park vs (you and me) went to the park (would be 'me went to the park without the 'you') OR 'I'm trying to do this for (you and) me' (this would be 'I'm trying to do this for I' without the 'you' and that sounds a little odd) Hope that makes sense! I'm not very good at explaining things..

더 빨리 진행하고 싶나요?

이 학습 커뮤니티에 참여하고 무료로 연습해보세요!

집에서 편안하게 언어를 배울 수 있는 기회를 놓치지 마세요. 경험 많은 강사진을 살펴보고 지금 바로 첫 수업을 신청하세요!

오늘 학습 시작하기