다양한 영어 선생님을 검색해 보세요...
France flagrachel커뮤니티 튜터
は/ が particles Hello, I have a question concerning these 2 sentences what is the difference between: 鍵はどこですか? 鍵が どこですか? If I want to say, "where are the keys ? " which one should I use and why ?

교정 · 4

0

は/ が particles


鍵はどこですか。(correct)
鍵がどこですか。(We don´t say this.)
If I want to say, "where are the keys ? " which one should I use and why ?


About the use of  は and  が, explain the reason WHY is very difficult for us because we always use them without thinking. In my opinion, it´s the big theme even between specialists and there is not any simple and clear explanation. If you use the appropriate one, it´s understandable without problem, only it would sound unnatural. So I¨d like you to use them and to get accustomed to them. Good luck!

La explication de base serait::

は = la particule de thème

が = la particule d´identification 

(http://www.guidetojapanese.org/french/particles.html)


J´espère que cela vous aidera. Désolée mon anglais et français.


0

When we say 〜が, a subject is the most important information in a sentence.


E.g.) 鍵がなくなった - THE KEYS were lost.

E.g.) 鍵が見つからない - I can’t find THE KEYS.


When we say 〜は, a subject is not a main information in a sentence.


E.g.) 鍵はどこですか? - WHERE are the keys?

E.g.) 鍵は引き出しの中です - the keys are IN THE DRAWER.

0

は/ が particles

Hello, I have a question concerning these 2 sentences
what is the difference between:
鍵はどこですか?
鍵が どこですか?
If I want to say, "where are the keys ? " which one should I use and why ?




If you want to ask where your key is, you have to say "鍵はどこですか。".  "鍵がどこですか。" is the wrong sentence.

ex)
たろうさんは どこですか。
あなたの ねこは どこですか。
にほんごの ほんは どこですか。
えきは どこですか。
スーパーは どこですか。


Anyway you did good job ceokophael. Keep it going.

0
Hi. ○ 鍵はどこですか? It's experimental knowledge, difficult to explain. I have a feeling that we almost use は when we ask questions. For example, Who is he? ○彼は だれですか? ×彼が だれですか? Thank you.

더 빨리 진행하고 싶나요?

이 학습 커뮤니티에 참여하고 무료로 연습해보세요!

집에서 편안하게 언어를 배울 수 있는 기회를 놓치지 마세요. 경험 많은 강사진을 살펴보고 지금 바로 첫 수업을 신청하세요!

오늘 학습 시작하기