Roman
My relatively late-life enrollment was the result of a what Why is there an "a" before word "what" in the following sentence? I don't undestand. It's from one book. My relatively late-life enrollment was the result of a what I believed then was a misspent youth and I was atoning for the indiscretions of what I call my ‘rock star’ 20’s.
2024년 4월 21일 오전 7:39
답변 · 11
2
I don't know why it's there either. It certainly doesn't need to be there, and I would assume it's actually an error or at the very least unnecessary.
2024년 4월 21일
1
You can have both a’s, no a’s, or a single ‘a’ in either place. The differences in meaning are very slight.
2024년 4월 22일
1
The sentence has this form: "My enrollment was the result of (a) NOUN." ("a", "the", "some", "my".... are optional) You can insert any noun or noun clause and you will have a correct sentence. For example: "My enrollment was the result of a whim." "My enrollment was the result of the balloon that I saw in the sky above one year ago." "My enrollment was a result of my cat's wayward ways." "My enrollment was the result of chocolate." ...and so forth. Determiners like "what" or "that" often introduce noun clauses: "What you think influences what you do." "That you sing is fortunate." "The floor being dirty is the result of what the dog did." "My enrollment was the result of what I believed was a misspent youth." To that, you can add determiners and it will still be correct because determiners can be placed in front of nouns: "My enrollment was the result of a what I believed was a misspent youth." "My enrollment was the result of my what I believed was a misspent youth." "My enrollment was the result of the what I believed was a misspent youth." The last three are a bit awkward, but they make grammatical sense. If I were to eliminate an "a", it is the SECOND one that I would eliminate: "My enrollment was the result of a what I believe to have been misspent youth."
2024년 4월 22일
give the whole sentence and then it will be clear why there's "a" there
2024년 4월 22일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!