Search from various 영어 teachers...
Ann
I‘m struggling with this question.Could you help me on this? There are many animals and vegetables on the farm. Does the word MANY describe the word ANIMALS or ANiMALS AND VEGETABLES ? If both are OK,does it mean that this sentence is ambiguous?
2024년 6월 18일 오전 11:33
답변 · 11
1
Hello Ann! As Simon said, it refers to both animals and vegetables. It is not ambiguous, and cannot mean "many animals and also an indeterminate amount of vegetables." It only means "many animals and many vegetables."
2024년 6월 18일
1
In order to get away from knowledge of farms, let's try "in my desk drawer there are many pens and pencils." I would expect this to mean both many pens and also many pencils. Why? Because if the speaker didn't mean this, they would have said something different, like: "In my desk drawer, there are many pens and a few pencils." "In my desk drawer, there are many pens and some pencils."
2024년 6월 18일
1
It means there are many animals and many vegetables. It's not ambiguous it only has one meaning - there are many animals and many vegetables on the farm.
2024년 6월 18일
1
It refers to both animals and vegetables
2024년 6월 18일
1
This is a fascinating question. I don't think this is a question of analyzing grammar, it's more of a question of how we understand real language in the real world. We understand it based on what we know about farms. As you have written it, I would expect it to refer to both animals and vegetables. It's not ambiguous. Here are two farms that do NOT have "many animals and vegetables:" Farm A has thirty pigs, fifty sheep, forty cows, and six tomato plants in the farmhouse garden. Farm B has two horses, twenty hectares of lettuce, twenty hectares of corn, and a twenty-hectare apple orchard. If a farm has "many animals" I would expect that to mean that if you counted the animals, it would be a large number. But I would also expect there to be several different KINDS of animal, to justify using the word "animal" instead of using the name of the particular animal. A farm that raises vegetables would always be a large number of individual plants, so I would expect "many vegetables" to mean "many different kinds of vegetable." When talking to children who experience the farm almost like a zoo, I would say "animals." In a more formal, adult, or professional context, I would use the uncountable noun "livestock" instead of "animals," and "crops" instead of "vegetables."
2024년 6월 18일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!

집에서 편안하게 언어를 배울 수 있는 기회를 놓치지 마세요. 경험 많은 강사진을 살펴보고 지금 바로 첫 수업을 신청하세요!