It's 聞きしに勝る(ききしにまさる). ~~ is even more~~ than I had heard.
Eg. She was even more beautiful than I had heard.
彼女は聞きしに勝る美人だった。
聞きし=the archaic form for the past tense form of the verb 聞く。
に= a case particle
勝る=Literally, win/defeat/surpass.
So it's like 聞いていたよりスゴイ。