영어 강사 찾기
Sarah Iulius
Negative Questions
How should I answer affirmatively to an negative question?
Please do me a favor and give an example
Thank you in advance
2013년 4월 6일 오후 9:51
답변 · 6
1
Don't you know?
Yes, of course, I know.
.
It is usually ambiguous & causes many misunderstandings. It is one of the things most needing repeating in English.
.
Sometimes it is easiest to not answer the question, but to say something that tells the person what you want to say. This is often a good general concept. Respond to questions rather than feel obliged to answer.
.
He didn't get the promotion? "No." sounds most like he did not get it.
He didn't get the promotion? "Yes." sounds just ambiguous.
"He got it" - simple.
.
It's not 4 o'clock yet, right?. "No" sounds like it is before 4.
It's not 4 o'clock yet, right?. "Yes" sounds just ambiguous
It's 3:55 - simple
.
Hope it helps.
2013년 4월 6일
Answers to negative questions are just plain ambiguous to this native speaker. Correct interpretation of the meaning of a short answer requires that both people know the convention. This, I find is usually lacking & the answer immediately gets queried to find out which was intended.
Don't you like Spaghetti? "yes" - would simply leave me wondering. .... This is made worse by popular use of double negatives for negative sentences. It ain't nothing. YUK!
2013년 4월 7일
Observe the following examples:
Affirmative Question: Do you like spaghetti?
Affirmative Answer: Yes, I do. (I like spaghetti.)
Negative Answer: No, I don't. (I don't like spaghetti.)
Negative Question: Don't you like spaghetti?
Affirmative Answer: Yes, I do. (I like spaghetti.)
Negative Answer: No, I don't. (I don't like spaghetti.)
When answering a question answerable by yes/no, the answer does not totally rely on the question. If your answer is negative you simple say No + another negative remark (No, I don't), and if affirmative you say Yes + positive remark (Yes, I do.)
This may be confusing for non-native English speakers because in other languages, the response relies on the question... like in Korean, if you ask them a negative question, they will say Yes first then say a negative remark to mean they agree to the negative question (that their answer is also negative.
Just remember in English, we say Yes + positive remark (for positive answers) and No + negative remark (for positive answers).
I hope this helps.
2013년 4월 6일
Observe the following examples:
Affirmative Question: Do you like spaghetti?
Affirmative Answer: Yes, I do. (I like spaghetti.)
Negative Answer: No, I don't. (I don't like spaghetti.)
Negative Question: Don't you like spaghetti?
Affirmative Answer: Yes, I do. (I like spaghetti.)
Negative Answer: No, I don't. (I don't like spaghetti.)
When answering a question answerable by yes/no, the answer does not totally rely on the question. If your answer is negative you simple say No + another negative remark (No, I don't), and if affirmative you say Yes + positive remark (Yes, I do.)
This may be confusing for non-native English speakers because in other languages, the response relies on the question... like in Korean, if you ask them a negative question, they will say Yes first then say a negative remark to mean they agree to the negative question (that their answer is also negative.
Just remember in English, we say Yes + positive remark (for positive answers) and No + negative remark (for positive answers).
I hope this helps.
2013년 4월 6일
Be positive :D
2013년 4월 6일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!