sirius
What are Appositions? Please elaborate using the following sentence. It was they who were to praise.
2013년 5월 17일 오후 1:07
답변 · 6
2
I believe the term is "appositive." It + was + they + who were to praise. a) We say that "who were to praise" is IN APPOSITION WITH "it." (That is, "who were to praise" explains the "it.") b) Native speakers do not accept "Who were to praise was they." c) So we start the sentence with "it." "It" is a substitute for the words "Who were to praise." d) It (who were to praise) + was + they. IMPORTANT: Some books have a different analysis: It = subject was = linking verb they = subjective complement who were to blame = adjective clause that modifies (refers) to "they." You will have to ask your teacher which analysis she or he expects.
2013년 5월 17일
2
http://www.ldoceonline.com/dictionary/apposition This sentence does not fit the usual definition of an appostion. I suppose 'they' and 'who were to praise' are both describing the same thing.
2013년 5월 17일
I believe the term is "appositive." It + was + they + who were to praise. a) We say that "who were to praise" is IN APPOSITION WITH "it." (That is, "who were to praise" explains the "it.") b) Native speakers do not accept "Who were to praise was they." c) So we start the sentence with "it." "It" is a substitute for the words "Who were to praise." d) It (who were to praise) + was + they. IMPORTANT: Some books have a different analysis: It = subject was = linking verb they = subjective complement who were to blame = adjective clause that modifies (refers) to "they." You will have to ask your teacher which analysis she or he expects.
2013년 5월 17일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!