Sasha
전문 강사
What is the correct answer here: "I predict that you ___ marry someone rich and famous"? What is the correct answer here: "I predict that you ___ marry someone rich and famous"? Why? A are going to B shall C are going to P.S.: I guess the correct answer should be "I predict that you WILL marry...", but there's no option like "will"... Thanks!
2014년 5월 21일 오전 11:36
답변 · 9
2
'Shall' should only be used with the first person singular and plural. 'Are going to' and 'will' are both fine.
2014년 5월 21일
2
My guess is that this is a typo and that the options should are A are going to B shall C will The best answer, as you correctly say, Sasha, is 'will'. 'are going to' is not the best answer because, as Morgan explains, this form usually indicates something pre-planned, so it isn't a prediction. That said, it is still possible. You can say 'I predict that .... is going to happen' in the sense that it seems inevitable. 'shall' is wrong. 'Shall' is only used with the second person ('you') when the speaker is being particularly insistent that something is the case, and is making a point of contradicting something previously said or believed. My favourite example of 'You shall....' is in the fairy tale Cinderella, when the fairy godmother waves her magic wand and exclaims 'You SHALL
2014년 5월 21일
1
A and C are the same, but "going to" in this sense means that the future has already been planned out. Therefore, it wouldn't be a prediction. B is the correct answer, as "shall" means that the future is not certain to them. It's the same as "will," which is why "will" wasn't an answer. "I predict that you SHALL marry someone rich and famous." Hope this helped! ^^
2014년 5월 21일
1
"Shall" is often used in place of "will"; it's fairly formal/old fashioned, but it still sees use sometimes.
2014년 5월 21일
..... OOPS. I pressed 'return' instead of caps lock. So to continue about 'shall'....The fairy godmother says to Cinderella 'You SHALL go to the ball' . Cinderella didn't believe she'd get to go to the ball, and the godmother is emphatically correcting her. She's being insistent, and contradicting what had previously been said or believed. In your example phrase above there is no contradiction, or previous suggestion that the person wasn't going to marry someone rich and famous, so I'm afraid that you can't use 'shall'.
2014년 5월 21일
더 보기
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!