Yasin
Passive voice or auxiliary verb+adjective Example: The windows are broken. Passive voice or auxiliary verb(be-->are)+adjective(broken)? How can I understand which of them?I would say "complementary verb".
2014년 7월 12일 오전 12:43
답변 · 12
In 'The window is broken', 'broken' MUST be an adjective. It is an adjective describing the state of the window and is the same structure as 'the window is dirty'. If it were passive voice, it would be possible to make an active sentence. It is not. '??? breaks the window' - this has vital information missing (who, when) and does not carry the same meaning as the original. It's the same with your additional sentence. BTW - In 'The window is broken', 'is' (be) is not an auxiliary verb. It is the main and only verb in the sentence. 'Be' is only an auxiliary when used with another verb to form other tenses or moods, e.g. Present Continuous, Passive Voice. If the sentence were 'the window has been broken' or 'the window is being broken', these would be Passive Voice' because we could also say 'somebody has broken the window' or 'somebody is breaking the window' and the meaning conveyed would be the same.
2014년 7월 12일
I would say it would be a linking verb "are" and an adjective "broken". If it were passive it would be more "The windows are being broken". I hope that answers your question.
2014년 7월 12일
Another example: He is trapped. Present simple passive voice or auxiliary verb(be-->is)+adjective(trapped)?
2014년 7월 12일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!