Search from various 영어 teachers...
Seda
song vs tune "You'd be amazed at the number of the songs you can play with only four chords." Is this sentence correct and natural. Should I use "tunes" instead of "songs"? Someone corrected it to "tunes" and I got confused. I know the difference between a tune and a song; a song has lyrics. I was indeed talking about a song and I hear people saying "playing songs..." all the time. Thanks in advance.
2014년 12월 23일 오후 9:05
답변 · 11
2
Either tunes or songs would work in this context. I agree with 马先生 that a song doesn't have to have lyrics. Many songs use only a limited number of chords. For example: http://www.guitarlessons.com/guitar-lessons/guitar-lessons-for-beginners/play-10-songs-with-4-chords/
2014년 12월 23일
1
The short answer is, a tune is a melody and a song is complete. You can't play a tune with four chords, but you can play a tune with four notes. If you have four chords, you can sing any tune that fits them (see my comment of 马先生's answer).
2014년 12월 23일
1
Firstly, a song doesn't need lyrics. "tune" often refers to the most memorable part of a song (the melody, no voice). You can use "tune" in place of "song" in some occasions - particularly songs that are repetitive like dance music, but usually a tune alone does not make a song. I don't know much about music, but I guess you can't make a whole song with only four chords.
2014년 12월 23일
1
One additional point to consider: when referring to a whole "song" as a "tune", it's a bit casual. You might say to your friends, "Let's play some tunes!" and mean "songs" . Outside of casual usage, to me, a "tune" is more the melody of a "song" than the "song" as a whole. A "tune" might be repeated multiple times within a "song". In your usage, about songs/tunes that can be played with a number of chords, since you are taking about the structure of the music, I'd see "song" and "tune" as different in the way I suggested. So either could be right, depending on what you mean.
2014년 12월 23일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!