Seda
song vs tune "You'd be amazed at the number of the songs you can play with only four chords." Is this sentence correct and natural. Should I use "tunes" instead of "songs"? Someone corrected it to "tunes" and I got confused. I know the difference between a tune and a song; a song has lyrics. I was indeed talking about a song and I hear people saying "playing songs..." all the time. Thanks in advance.
2014년 12월 23일 오후 9:05
답변 · 11
2
Either tunes or songs would work in this context. I agree with 马先生 that a song doesn't have to have lyrics. Many songs use only a limited number of chords. For example: http://www.guitarlessons.com/guitar-lessons/guitar-lessons-for-beginners/play-10-songs-with-4-chords/
2014년 12월 23일
1
The short answer is, a tune is a melody and a song is complete. You can't play a tune with four chords, but you can play a tune with four notes. If you have four chords, you can sing any tune that fits them (see my comment of 马先生's answer).
2014년 12월 23일
1
Firstly, a song doesn't need lyrics. "tune" often refers to the most memorable part of a song (the melody, no voice). You can use "tune" in place of "song" in some occasions - particularly songs that are repetitive like dance music, but usually a tune alone does not make a song. I don't know much about music, but I guess you can't make a whole song with only four chords.
2014년 12월 23일
1
One additional point to consider: when referring to a whole "song" as a "tune", it's a bit casual. You might say to your friends, "Let's play some tunes!" and mean "songs" . Outside of casual usage, to me, a "tune" is more the melody of a "song" than the "song" as a whole. A "tune" might be repeated multiple times within a "song". In your usage, about songs/tunes that can be played with a number of chords, since you are taking about the structure of the music, I'd see "song" and "tune" as different in the way I suggested. So either could be right, depending on what you mean.
2014년 12월 23일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!