Alison Lam
"doch" and "noch" Hey guys! What's the difference between "doch" and "noch"? They sometimes appear in the same sentence and i don't really know how it could be used. Thanks everyone who helps me with this:)
2015년 2월 27일 오전 10:41
답변 · 7
1
It would be easier to translate the sentences that contain these words in order for you to understand it in your own cases. However, here are some examples: "Doch war ich noch da als du mich angerufen hast" - "Yes, I was still there when you called me" In this (colloquial) sentence, 'doch' is not easily translated, but it's something along the lines of 'yes', after someone for instance has asked the person whether they were still at the party when they were called. "Du bist doch noch ein Mitglied, nicht wahr?" - "You are still a member, right?" In that sentence, 'doch' is emphasizing the question "..right?" - again not easily translated. In both example cases, 'noch' means still. Please post some example questions if you are still unsure - these words are not always easily translated.
2015년 2월 27일
1
Vesa is correct. Noch means still while doch is hard to translate. For example: A: Einstein ist klüger als du. (Einstein is smarter than you.) B: Doch. (Nope.) Here's a video that might help explain doch further. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bVkKjyt-Qs8
2015년 2월 27일
I can tell you Doch is but and noch is yet that's about as helpful as I can be .. I know a lot of words, doch cant figure out the sentence structure noch ! Haha .. Good luck
2015년 2월 27일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!