Hamed
Which sentence sounds natural? Is bigger always the better? Is it bigger always the better? I sometimes see the structure [Is + verb] and sometimes [Is + it + verb] Are both the same? More examples: Is drinking ice water bad for you? Is it drinking ice water bad for you?
2015년 3월 30일 오전 9:52
답변 · 2
delete the 'it' in these sentences. Is drinking iced water bad for you? If you want to leave out 'iced water' because it is quite clear to the listener what you are talking about, then you can substitute 'it' - is drinking it bad for you? But you don't need both, as they are both describing the same thing. Is bigger always better? You can't really leave out the bigger and substitute 'it' in this example, as it is substituting for an adjective rather than a noun. And you certainly don't say 'is it bigger always better'. An example of is+it+verb, might be - is it working? Here again we have substituted 'it' for a noun. Is (it) the computer, working? So in these examples, think if 'it' as being a substitute for the noun, and if you wouldn't put the noun in a particular position, then don't put the it there either. I hope that is helpful.
2015년 3월 30일
For your sentence: "Is drinking ice water bad for you?" -> drinking here becomes a gerund [hence a noun] so the verb drinking here is your subject "Is it drinking ice water bad for you?" -> no need to add "it" you can either say "Is drinking ice water bad for you?" or "Is it bad for you?" - it referring to" drinking ice water"
2015년 3월 30일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!