Alberto
Pictograms VS radicals What is the difference between a radical and a pictogram (or ideogram). I know what they both are (so, please, no basic explanations) but they seem the same to me. Is a radical just an ideogram inside another character? Can every pictogram (or ideogram) work as a radical and viceversa? Thanks
2015년 4월 30일 오후 6:38
답변 · 7
3
I view radicals analogous to Latin root words (e.g. aero-, anti-). So some radicals are themselves words and pictograms. However, not all pictograms are radicals. For instance, 木 is a radical and a pictogram (looks like a tree, right?), but the words 林 and 森 all have the same root radical, 木, and are pictograms, but are not themselves radicals. A bit of trivia, when we used paper dictionaries, words were arranged by radicals.
2015년 4월 30일
2
①Is a radical just an ideogram inside another character? YES For example: "她"(she/her) "妈"(mom) "姨"(aunt) "好"(good/ok), they have common radical--女 The radicals sometimes impact on the meaning of characters, as is shown above,"她,妈,姨" are all feminine. "狗(dog)" "猫"(cat) "猪"(pig) "狐狸"(fox),etc characters with "犭" are normally animals. "病"(disease) "癌症"(cancer) "痛"(hurt) characters with "疒 " are disease or something bad. It will help you lean chinese character by heart and guess the meaning of news words the first time you mee them. ②Can every pictogram (or ideogram) work as a radical? NO. We have set radicals.
2015년 4월 30일
this approach doesn't seem correct to me... because the general concept is too misty for beginners, takes much time to remember what is radical, what is not and why (usually no why)... to make it simple -- Chinese symbols are pictures which consists of a set of parts 塔 = 塔 = 土 plus 艹 plus 人 plus 一 plus 口, these parts can be meaningless 艹 or meaningful 口 and some of them are chosen as index parts, to divide all symbols into certain groups
2015년 5월 4일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!