다양한 영어 선생님을 검색해 보세요...
[삭제됨]
Is there any scientific way to learn English tones? Unlike Chinese, English tones is depend on the structure of sentences rather than charaters(or words). I'm surprised that many native English speaker say there is no tone in English, but there is. When Chinese speak English, their tones are flat, because they don't know what tone to use since in Chinese each character has its own tone. I do think English tones are depend on the emphasis and sentence structure, like your tone is up a bit when you're asking a question and pronouncing the word before "and". For example, when you read "We talked for hours and hours", your tone is up a bit when reading the first "hour" and down a bit when reading the second "hour". But in Chinese, if it is the same word they sound exactly the same... I find it kinda difficult learning English tones. Does anyone know any ways to decode how English tones work?

답변 · 5

3
You are definitely on the right track, and I'm sure if you continue to listen to native speakers, you'll pick it up soon enough. I teach this in my classes, and I have some techniques, but I haven't had a chance to write an article on it yet. Basically, if you were working on your own, you would identity some categories like you've already mentioned -- questions, statements, lists, rhetorical questions, sarcasm etc, listen to examples, and learn them like you would learn a song. I hope this helps.
2
English really does have no tones. Native speakers mostly just use completely random intonation, which happens subconsciously. Different speakers will pronounce the exact same sentence with different tones, and if you ask an English speaker to repeat the same sentence back to you, chances are they'll use completely different intonation for the exact same sentence the second time round. I've actually tested this: if someone asks you to repeat a sentence and you use the exact same intonation as you did the first time, they will be taken aback and say you sound robotic! Here's something else I've tested: I asked one of my friends (who had never learned Chinese) if he could hear the difference between "ma" pronounced in each of the first four tones of Chinese. He was confused and just said "You're just saying the exact same thing four times, aren't you?". I repeated the sounds multiple times and he still couldn't hear a difference. All you need to know about intonation in English is this: 1) If a sentence is a question, the final syllable should be rising. 2) Swear words should in the falling tone. 3) For every other syllable, all you need to do is to make sure there's no distinguishable pattern. If every syllable is flat, if you repeat the same tones in a pattern or if you "speak a song", you will sound like a robot. Just make your intonation completely random so there's no discernible pattern. That's all there is to it.
1
No, there isn't a scientific way; English and Chinese tones do not correlate. We use intonation and stress to convey extra meaning beyond the words, and the meaning of a sentence can change entirely if we change the stress or intonation. That is, English intonation is not necessarily connected with the words. However, you can look at intonation as "shaping" whole sentences and phrases. The last syllable in a sentence usually gets a down tone, which obviously means "this is the end of the sentence". Questions usually get an up tone, but this is not a fixed rule. You'll also hear that the syllable before a comma has its own tone, which we English-speakers understand as "the sentence isn't finished yet; there's still more". Some accents have a certain musicality and intonations which make them distinct. One thing to remember is that we do follow a "weak-strong" rhythm in our syllables (again, usually but not a fixed rule), so this may explain why you might hear a flat tone from non-native speakers. The rhythm isn't there.
0
Such a detailed question! In my opinion, it is more about the ability to fluently speak English, rather than knowing what tone to use when you're speaking.. The smoother you are, the better/ more natural you will feel about using English. I have made people from more than 15 countries around the world and I noticed that there is no "correct tone" or "the right tone" in English as everyone speaks a bit differently according to who, when, what and why they're speaking to each other. Just some thoughts sharing :) It is a worth-thinking question!

아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?

질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!

집에서 편안하게 언어를 배울 수 있는 기회를 놓치지 마세요. 경험 많은 강사진을 살펴보고 지금 바로 첫 수업을 신청하세요!

오늘 학습 시작하기