Is this correct, 'On the bus to school, I can talk with my classmates about news'?
Thank you!!
다양한 영어 선생님을 검색해 보세요...
답변 · 8
1
Two points of grammar here:
1. "Talk to" and "talk with".
There are obviously other more urgent and important matters in the world, but, as you know, there has been considerable discussion for many years around the world whether "talk with" is an admissible form. It depends on where you are. Opinions are divided, but in the U.S., most people think it is. The classic form is "talk to", and in Britain I think this is the form most frequently used.
2. The news.
We always have to add "the" when we say "talk about the news". "The news" means current affairs and other information freshly published or made known.
A further point:
3. "On the bus to school"
I think we say "On the bus going to school" (public transport included) or "On the school bus" (bus dedicated to the school run), but not "On the bus to school"
So, the answer is, "On the bus going to school, I can talk to/with my classmates about the news."
Helen, I think you need to read more, and given that everyone has limited time, you probably should spend less time micro-managing your commonplace book and more time on reading immersion. You are at that stage of your progress where the one thing you need most is reading well-written contemporary English. That probably means reading www.bbc.com for 45 minutes every day.
1
It depends on what kind of "news" you mean. If you mean TV/newspaper/radio news,
then (at least in American English) you would use "the news":
"On the bus to school, I can talk with my classmates about the news."
If you just say "news", that sounds like personal news: news about school, news about family and
friends. If that is what you meant to say, then the sentence is OK. I think, though, that you meant
TV news.
On the other hand, in a list, people often leave out "the":
"On the bus to school, I can talk with my classmates about sports, news, and homework."
That still sounds like it means the TV news, even without "the".
I think "the news" is just a set expression (idiom) for public (TV/newspaper) news. That is why
it has "the": everyone understands that means a particular kind of news, namely broadcast or newspaper news.
"Did you watch the news today?" It is a special kind of news, so it gets a "the". Everyone just understands that it means public news.
But you also say "the news" when you are talking about
a specific piece of personal news: "Did you hear the news about her brother? He is moving to Australia!"
You would never say (incorrect sentence:) "I can talk to my friends about the sports." It is always "sports", unless you are
talking about specific sports:
(correct) "I can talk to my friends about the sports they like", because you have picked out some particular sports, from sports in general. (You could also leave out "the" in this sentence, it would still be OK.)
"
0
It is correct! :-)
0
Rudy, that's a good contribution.
In that regard, I might add, just to help Helen, that for "personal news", we would normally say "catch up on news" and not "talk about news".
Example: "Let's sit down for a cup of coffee and catch up on news."
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!
집에서 편안하게 언어를 배울 수 있는 기회를 놓치지 마세요. 경험 많은 강사진을 살펴보고 지금 바로 첫 수업을 신청하세요!
오늘 학습 시작하기
