Lux
Inversion Please help me with this question, which answer is correct? In front of the door.... A. a dog sat B. was seated a dog C. seated a dog D. was a dog seating
2016년 4월 3일 오전 2:44
답변 · 6
1
As a teacher/grammarian, I'd say B, as it follows the grammatical rules of inversion. As an ordinary English speaker, however, I'd say 'None of these'. They are all extremely unnatural. Nobody would ever say 'In front of the door was seated a dog'. For a start, the inversion is awkward. Also, the use of 'to be seated' is very strange. If you say, for example, 'The audience must be seated by 7 pm', this means that the people must sitting on their seats by that time. People can be seated, but dogs are not normally seated. I suspect this was written either by a non-native, or by a native speaker who had had their head in a grammar book for so long that they had lost sight of what a real English sentence sounds like. Don't waste your time on such awkward and pointless exercises.
2016년 4월 3일
Thank you :)
2016년 4월 3일
Yes, B is what I would choose as the correct answer. For A to be correct, it would have to be "In front of the door sat a dog". Correct, C and D require the verb "to sit" (C-sat a dog / D-was a sitting dog)
2016년 4월 3일
In front of the door was seated a dog => B (be seated = sit down so we can't choose C or D right?)
2016년 4월 3일
I shall give you a hint. Inversion means "verb-subject order" instead of the normal "subject-verb order". In normal subject-verb order, we would say: NORMAL ORDER INVERTED ORDER "A dog was seated in front of the door." => In front of the door _____ (verb-subject) "A dog sat in front of the door." => In front of the door _____ (verb-subject) Based on this hint, which answer do you think is correct?
2016년 4월 3일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!