영어 강사 찾기
Zelox.Dell
What were/are they doing in the photo?
What were/are they doing in the photo?
Suppose someone is showing me a photo. There are many people in that photo. I want to ask what those people do in the photo. So, grammatically, I should use past tense because this photo is taken in the past, and those people may have stoped and left the place. But, "what were they doing" sounds more odd to me. I'm here for comfirmation. Thanks in advance.
2017년 1월 26일 오전 2:49
답변 · 5
1
If you are looking at a photo, this means you see the action in the photo at this moment.
"What are they doing in the photo?"
It doesn't matter how long ago the photo was taken. You see the action in the present moment, and that's how you describe it.
2017년 1월 26일
1
Both are OK, but "are" is better than "were". When describing a creative production (a book, a movie, a painting, o a photograph), we usually use present tense, since the production still exists. For example, we would usually say, "In this movie, a man *fights* a dinosaur."
If the main reason we're talking is to tell a story instead of describing the book or movie that contains the story, we will use past tense instead of present. This usually happens if the description is longer than two sentences or so. For Example: "I saw a movie yesterday. It was about a man who fought a dinosaur. He punched it, and it clawed at him. Then, some aliens came and killed both the man and the dinosaur."
2017년 1월 26일
Are you asking what the people are doing in the photo (as the photo was taken)? Or are you asking what the people do, as in what they do for work? I will assume, for now, that you mean the former; so, if you are shown a photo of people and you are asking what they are doing as the photo was taken you could say: "What are they doing in this photo" or "What were they doing in this photo". "What are they doing" and "What were they doing" would also suffice since it can be assumed that you are talking about the photo. Let me know if this helps or not. Peace.
2017년 1월 26일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!
Zelox.Dell
언어 구사 능력
중국어(북경어), 중국어(대만어), 영어
학습 언어
중국어(대만어), 영어
좋아할 수도 있는 읽을거리

How to Read and Understand a Business Contract in English
6 좋아요 · 1 댓글

6 Ways italki Can Help You Succeed in Your School Language Classes
10 좋아요 · 6 댓글

The Power of Storytelling in Business Communication
46 좋아요 · 13 댓글
다른 읽을거리