Min
Can "that" or "when" be omitted here? This is the sentence: "Every time that/when the phone rings, he goes nervous." The grammar book says "that" or "when" can be omitted here. I was wondering whether the same rule applies to the next sentence. "He came at a time when we needed him most." Can "that" be used to replace "when"? And can both of them be omitted like what it is in the first sentence? Thank you.
2017년 8월 30일 오후 3:07
답변 · 9
It actually sounds more natural when "that/when" is omitted from the first sentence "Every time the phone rings, he goes nervous." Also, it is correct to replace "goes" with "gets", so the correct and natural sentence would be "Every time the phone rings, he gets nervous." As for the second sentence, "He came at a time when we needed him most", it is more appropriate to keep the word "when" rather than using "that" or omitting it. In fact, the sentence would sound more natural to omit the phrase "at a time". This would make the most natural form of the sentence be "He came when we needed him most". Hope this helps! Let me know if you need an explanation.
2017년 8월 30일
Hi Min, In your first sentence, omitting "when/"that" sounds fine. However, we don't say "goes nervous", but rather, "gets nervous." Therefore, the sentence should be "Every time the phone rings, he gets nervous." As for your second sentence, omitting "when" sounds unnatural. As for replacing it with "that", that also sounds unnatural.
2017년 8월 30일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!