Can or will be able to, 1st Conditional
Hello!
I am confused by the use of can/be able to in 1st conditional type of sentences.
According to New Inside Out (Intermediate), I can use 'can' in the main clause in the following cases:
1. If you're spending any time in London, I can recommend a great hotel.
2. If he finds out the truth, you can forget about our holiday in Rome.
I already know that we use modals in this type of sentences to express possibility, permission, obligation and suggestion. We also use 1st conditional to express threats or warnings. So it will be suggestion (1), threat (2).
But with action verbs it becomes more confusing and the book doesn't give any examples with them.
Thus in examples such as:
1. If it doesn't rain tomorrow, I can go for a run.
Will it mean something like "I will be permitted to go for a run"?
2. If it doesn't rain tomorrow, I will be able to go for a run.
"It will be physically possible for me to go for a run because I don't like getting wet"?
I would be grateful for any help <3
다양한 영어 선생님을 검색해 보세요...
답변 · 4
4
Consider these sentences:
Possibility
a) If you give me some money now, I can / I will be able to buy some chocolate. [present into the future]
b) If you give me some money tomorrow, I can / I will be able buy some chocolate. [only from a future time]
In a) and b), "can" and "will be able to" refer to possibility. "can" is more common and more informal than "will be able to".
We prefer "will be able to" also when we want to emphasise that the possibility will start from a future point and not from around now.
Skill/ability
c) If I learn Italian every week for a year, I will be able to speak Italian.
I cannot use "can" here. The meaning demands "will be able to" because I need to explain that the ability or skill will only begin at a future point.
4
I'd say "to be able to" describes more of a physical ability (=to have the ability to do something), whereas "can" is more like a possibility in general, although lines aren't always as clear cut.
I am able to swim = I know how to swim
I can swim = swimming is an option for me in a particular situation (but also: I know how to swim as a general statement)
compare also: ability/disability/enable/disable
3
You use either CAN or BE ABLE TO when talking about decisions and future arrangements.
> 1. If it doesn't rain tomorrow, I can go for a run.
> Will it mean something like "I will be permitted to go for a run"?
No. Most likely it means a possibility or an option for me to go for a run.
2. If it doesn't rain tomorrow, I will be able to go for a run.
"It will be physically possible for me to go for a run because I don't like getting wet"?
And again, no, I will most likely have that option of going for a run (unless your legs are broken:))
You use either CAN or BE ABLE TO when talking about decisions and future arrangements:
"If it doesn't rain tomorrow, I can go for a run. = If it doesn't rain tomorrow, I will be able to go for a run."
0
Thanks everyone! :)
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!
집에서 편안하게 언어를 배울 수 있는 기회를 놓치지 마세요. 경험 많은 강사진을 살펴보고 지금 바로 첫 수업을 신청하세요!
오늘 학습 시작하기
