Search from various 영어 teachers...
Sophie
Differentiating how/why Japanese interrogatives? なんで、どう、どうして、どうやって
こんにちはみんなさん、
I have a really big test on Monday so any help would be appreciated.
Could someone help me find the best way to define the differences between these interrogatives? I have put the definitions I have so far for them, but some of them are so similar!
My textbook is みんなの日本語
なんで
Textbook: why/how casual
Dictionary: why, what for, how by what means
なにで
Textbook: more emphasis on how than なんで, less casual
this didn't show up in my dictionary
どう
Textbook: Nはどうですか asking about an impression
Dictionary: how, in what way, how about
どうして
Textbook: asking the reason for something
Dictionary: why, for what reason, how, in what way, for what purpose, what for
どうやって
Textbook: way or how to do something
Dictionary: how, in what way, by what means
So what is the difference between:
どうやって and どう and なんで /なにで
and
どうして and なんで
Is there a better way to define/differentiate these?
ありがとうございます、
ソフィー
2018년 3월 22일 오전 3:53
답변 · 3
2
I'll try to explain roughly.
**** There are two groups.
- group 1 「何」 ('NANI' or 'NAN', a broken sound)
「なにで」「なんで」
- group 2 「どう」
「どう」「どうして」「どうやって」
*** About the group 1.
-「何」 = what
-「で」=「にて」=「に」+「て」
「に」: place, target of action, where you are, where you do to.
「て」: indicating 'completion' in terms of aspect
then
「で」means: platform of action, where you do.
「なにで」: with/on what? -> 【using what?】(syntactically OK, but rarely used)
「なんで」: with/on what -> (sound broken) -> 【why ?】
※ なんでそんなことしたの? why did you do such a thing?
*** About the group 2
- 「どう」: how
※ 君たちはどう生きるか?
(how do you live your life? )
- 「どうして」≓「どうやって」 : 【how/why】
して is a polite form of 'やって'
※ どうしてそんなことするの? why do you do such a thing?
※ どうしたらそんなことになるの? how come it become so ?
※ どうやってこの苦境を脱するか?
how (=through what) do we get out of this hardship?
- 「どうして」=「どう」+「して」
by doing how
-> in what way do you reach here
-> tell me the process
-> 【why 】
※ どうしてそんなことするの? why do you do such a thing?
2018년 3월 24일
1
なんで is WHY. なんで 日本語を勉強しますか。Why do you learn Japanese. 日本へ行きたいですから。Because I want to go to Japan.
なんで is also BY WHAT. 何で 大学へいきますか。You go to the school by What? バスで大学へいきます。I go to the school by bus。
If you take the whole "なんで" in a phase, it means WHY
And if you separate it like two individual words, ”なん” and ”で”, it means BY WHAT (Nで V - Do V by using N)。
So my teacher said that to make it more clear, younger today tend to pronounce "なにで" with the one with meaning "BY WHAT" or "HOW" (何 has two ways to read なんーなに, depend on which word follows it.)
**********************************************
どうやって and どう and なんで /なにで
***
どうやって : How to do ... . どう: How / やって : やります:Do
どうやって 大学へ行きましたか How did you do to go to school?
ー>私のうちから Mariaさんのうちまで あるきました。そして、Mariaさんのバイクで大学へ行きました I walked from my house to Maria House. Then I take her motorbike to run to the school.
***
どう: How。 to ask about characteristic
あの人はどうですか。How is that person?
ー>とてもハンサムです。Very handsome
***
なんで/なにで: By what as I said above
**********************************************
どうして and なんで
I think they are the same. Maybe just the different about the politeness
Sorry about my bad English.
2018년 3월 24일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!
Sophie
언어 구사 능력
네덜란드어, 영어, 프랑스어, 일본어
학습 언어
네덜란드어, 프랑스어, 일본어
좋아할 수도 있는 읽을거리

Same Word, Different Meaning: American, British, and South African English
11 좋아요 · 8 댓글

How to Sound Confident in English (Even When You’re Nervous)
13 좋아요 · 11 댓글

Marketing Vocabulary and Phrases for Business English Learners
10 좋아요 · 4 댓글
다른 읽을거리