Search from various 영어 teachers...
Arnaud
Why the instrumental case in that sentence?
Никто не надеялся увидеть их снова живыми
2018년 4월 11일 오전 6:53
답변 · 16
2
From Wikipedia: "The instrumental case in Russian is not limited to its instrumental thematic role. It is also used to denote ... a predicate with a number of ... verbs, denoting state, appearance, manner, consideration, etc."
2018년 4월 11일
Никто не надеялся увидеть их снова живыми людьми. "Людьми" is a missing word here, which is a noun in instrumental case.
2018년 4월 11일
There is no instrumental case in that sentence. It is accusative.
В этом предложении нет творительного падежа. Есть винительный. Отвечает на вопросы "кого?" и "что?".
Кого никто не надеялся увидеть снова живыми ?
Их
2018년 4월 11일
It's the predicative instrumental case that is used in predicative expressions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predicative_expression.
2018년 4월 17일
Thanks K P, always interesting to read you. I'm going to note what you explained and think about it, obviously there is a gap in my understanding of the instrumental case, although as you said, I meet it often in literature (btw, the sentence was taken from a children book)
2018년 4월 12일
더 보기
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!


