Search from various 영어 teachers...
Will
Can someone explain the use of the subjunctive here?
Hi, probably a simple question but I came across this sentence in a news article and was not totally sure of the use of the subjunctive here. Will someone be so kind as to help me understand why? The sentence is:
Las medidas, presentadas el lunes por el Ministerio de Justicia, cubrirán a todos los ciudadanos extranjeros que vivan en Japón, incluyendo estudiantes.
2018년 12월 17일 오후 11:10
답변 · 6
1
This is a borderline case of 'possible non-reality'. In the more obvious case of 'busco unos zapatos que sean cómodos' the subjunctive signals that such shoes might not exist.
Here we could more comfortably use the indicative 'que viven' on the assumption that there actually are foreigners living in Japan, the subjunctive is a pedantic touch here, making no such assumption.
Juan Carlos is correct to point out possible future foreign residents as an extension of the possible present ones covered by the above.
2018년 12월 17일
1
Since it refers to a condition to be met, the use of subjunctive is necessary. This will often be the case when talking about law or something that has to do with requirements. Take this example: Los motociclistas que no utilicen el casco tendrán una multa de un salario mínimo. Hope this helps.
2018년 12월 18일
Este uso del presente de subjuntivo es para expresar una idea virtual sobre el futuro. Si lo cambiamos a presente de indicativo cambia el signficado y se referiría a todos los habitantes actuales de Japón.
Ej: Las medidas, presentadas el lunes por el Ministerio de Justicia, cubrirán a todos los ciudadanos extranjeros que viven en Japón, incluyendo estudiantes.
2018년 12월 20일
This an advise sentence, or and futur idea
2018년 12월 17일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!



