"I made a mistake (??) moving here?" What's the proposition it saves in bracket! Is it "in", "by"..
"I made a mistake (??) moving here?" What's the proposition it saves in bracket! Is it "in", "by" or "of" ? Same question for "I have a great time (??) hanging out with my friends".
다양한 영어 선생님을 검색해 보세요...
답변 · 6
3
"By" is what I would use with "moving here." However, you can also say, "I made a mistake in moving here." Might sound weird, but if you flip it, you'll see:
In moving here, I made a mistake.
As a teacher, I would not mark that incorrect.
3
For the first question "by" is correct. It expresses a consequence or a result of an action. For "I have a great time (??) hanging out with my friends" it is a little different. Neither "by" nor "in" nor "of" are correct. Correct would be "I have a great time hanging out with my friends" or "I have a great time while hanging out with my friends". Maybe someone can explain the grammar behind this as I'm answering purely from my gut feeling ;)
3
Hi Ethan!
I made a mistake *by* moving here is what I hear most frequently.
I have a great time hanging out with my friends. (no preposition)
2
Hey Ethan,
Firstly, you should know that the preposition ''by'' can (and not ''must'') be used with an -ing form to say how something is achieved. So, as regards your first sentence, it is correct for you to say either ''I made a mistake in moving here'' (See the ''Notice Topic'' below) or ''I made a mistake by moving here''. Both sentences are correct, though the former may be used less often than the latter.
As for your second sentence, I should tell you that no preposition is needed. It is correct to just say ''I have a great time hanging out with my friends.'' As Sascha has mentioned, the usage or not of the word ''while'' falls upon you. ''While'', when used followed by a gerund (''...while hanging out with my friends''), means the same as ''during the activity of (doing something).''
NOTICE: I shall provide you with additional information regarding your first question. As previously explained, the usage of ''by'' in a sentence is to clearly describe the way which something has been achieved. For the other words inquired by you, such as ''of'' and ''in'', they are used in different contexts. You may see the preposition ''in'' being used to mean ''during the act or process of'', as in ''I continued to walk and in doing so I ran into a misterious cave'' or ''I was nearly run over by a bus in crossing the street the other day''. For the latter example, you could replace ''in'' with ''while'' if you pleased so. As opposed to ''in'', the preposition ''of'', when followed by a gerund, is used to indicate either the object of the action noted by the preceding noun, verb, or adjective or an aspiration (a goal to be achieved or to have a longing for), as in ''He was tired of working at the office'' or ''I can't but dream of owning my own business one day''.
Hope that helps!!!
1
不一样的意味... 要看全部的情况而用
BY... 怎样/移动/搬到/, 识别动因 (identifying the agent in performing an action/means in achieving the action)
IN... 怎样移/搬進
OF... 怎样搬动的
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!
집에서 편안하게 언어를 배울 수 있는 기회를 놓치지 마세요. 경험 많은 강사진을 살펴보고 지금 바로 첫 수업을 신청하세요!
오늘 학습 시작하기
