다양한 영어 선생님을 검색해 보세요...
Brazil flagThiago Gualdi V.
Syntactic Hierarchy So, in other questions I tried to use a generic, neutral word for a piece of writting from the beginning to the final dot having it subject and predicate or not. e.g. 'He works.' is a sentence. 'Ah!' is not a sentence. I know the followings: Morpheme (Morfema) Word (Palavra) Phrase (Sintagma) Clause (Oração) Sentence (Período) --- (Frase) Is there a grammar term like 'Frase' to refer to both examples up there? And, if any, could you present me to other common terms like those and their academic usage?

답변 · 4

1
Both of your examples are sentences. "He works" is a major sentence. It has a subject and a predicate. A major sentence is a sentence that can be broken down by sentence analysis, using terms that include: subject, clause, phrase, verb, etc. It is sometimes called a regular sentence or a full sentence. "Ah!" is a minor sentence. Some other minor sentences: Standing room only. (sign) Coffer or tea? (phrasal question) Hi. (conventional utterance) Wow! (interjection) Cheaper By the Dozen. ( title) Back to square one. (idiom) Fifteen men on a a dead man's chest Yo ho ho and a bottle of rum! {Robert Louis Stevenson} ( poetry, nominal sentences,etc) A minor sentence cannot be broken down by sentence analysis. It does not conform to the normal sentence pattern and is sometimes called an irregular sentence, a sentence fragment, or a non-sentence.
1
Here would be my hierarchy: phoneme (single unit of sound) grapheme (the smallest written representation of one sound) syllable (combination of phonemes, with or without meaning) morpheme (combination of phonemes and syllables, each with meaning) word phrase clause sentence paragraph Anything "less than a sentence" is either a phrase, a clause, or one of the following: an utterance -- anything spoken, no matter how short or long Ex.: "Ah!" - when spoken. an expression -- any written or spoken unit which can be understood, whether grammatical or not Ex.: "Ah!" - when written or spoken. a response -- which assumes grammatical parts from its question Example: Person A: "What time is dinner?" Person B: "Five." Person B has made an utterance, an expression and a response. It was spoken, it had meaning, and it had implied grammar (i.e., "Dinner is at five o'clock.") based on the question.
0
is your problem refering to portuguese? different grammars use different names or categories, specially if talking about different languages. Jura is right for english grammar normative. i should have a look on it. one thing i can tell you now is that morpheme is not a syntatic concept or category and symtagma doesn't equals phrase. normally a phrase, as i understand the term contains a verbal syntagma and may have a nominal syntagma. here the thing it is how the language works....one verbal syntagma phrase is "llueve" or "chove" /spanish/portuguese but english say "it rains" which contains an explicit (grammatical) subject. i need to check the theory.
0
Hi, have you mistaken a phrase for a clause in a basic sentence? 1. A basic sentence is composed of at least one independent clause. A clause is composed of a minimum of a subject and a predicate. Without one of these elements, the clause is ungrammatical. 2. A subject of a clause is an entity such as a person, a place, an object, or an abstract concept, which acts, is described or is acted upon. The subject usually answers the question Who/What is the sentence about? The subject in the "right or wrong" example is "a black snake." The lion roared. [The subjects acts] The lion is beautiful. [The subject is described] The lion was hunted. [The subject is acted upon]

아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?

질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!

집에서 편안하게 언어를 배울 수 있는 기회를 놓치지 마세요. 경험 많은 강사진을 살펴보고 지금 바로 첫 수업을 신청하세요!

오늘 학습 시작하기