Which is incorrect. (When/Why) is it that no one listens to me anymore? Question from a book written by a Chinese writer: Question: ______ is it that no one listens to me anymore? (a)When (b)Did

Search from various 영어 teachers...

liveoutmyway

Which is incorrect. (When/Why) is it that no one listens to me anymore? Question from a book written by a Chinese writer: Question: ______ is it that no one listens to me anymore? (a)When (b)Did (c)Why (d)Do the book gives me "(a)When" as the only answer based on the Semantic meaning (context) -------------- But I think "(a)When and (c)Why" are all possible and correct. In my opinion They are all CLEFT SENTENCES. 1. It is WHY that no one listens to me anymore.= No one listens to me anymore because ... 2. It is WHEN that no one listens to me anymore. =No one listens to me anymore (by the time). If there is anything wrong in my opinion, please help to correct. Thank you for your attention.

2019년 9월 22일 오후 5:53

답변 · 24

The answer is absolutely "why," and really can't be "when." "Why is it that no one listens to me anymore?" is a completely natural English sentence. As Lackadai says, it would be /possible/ to imagine someone asking about the specific times when no one listens to them, but a) this would be a very strange thing to ask, b) this would be a very awkward way to ask that question, and c) even if you did ask the question "when," you would have to remove the word "anymore" in order for the question to be grammatically correct. I agree with Bramwell -- the book you're using seems to have some serious mistakes. It would be better to find a different book to learn from, if possible.

2019년 9월 22일

This should be: Why is it that no one listens to me anymore? (Here the person speaking is asking for the reason) With "when" it would only work if you port it like this: Since when does no one listen to me anymore? (The focus is here on when they listening stopped). Or: When no one listens to me anymore ...

2019년 9월 22일

@Dear Gray: I don't know why and how your (and my )whole reply disappear. It's a pity that all meaningful information can't be left to someone who may need this in the future.

2019년 9월 27일

@Cristiano Sorry I didn't get your point. Would you mind to explain more? Thank you for your reply anyway.

2019년 9월 23일

@Bramwell Thank Gray and your advice. There are 2 wrong out of 3, from all 3 questions I recently raised from the same book. I think I will/should read other books to learn from instead.

2019년 9월 23일

아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?

질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!