Using はvsを
I tried to translate "I will not buy chairs" as 椅子を買いません but the website corrected を to は. I thought を is for direct objects ?
다양한 영어 선생님을 검색해 보세요...
답변 · 3
1
In Japanese, when you negate something, you usually use は.
It is not a strict rule but a strong tendency.
そうではありません。
それは違います。
あなたのことは好きではありません。
ラーメンはキライです。
そこには行きません。
夕食は食べません。
そういうことは認めません。
これではいけない。
That is why the website thought 椅子を買いません is unnatural and corrected を to は.
The sentence (私は)椅子を買いません seems a little bit odd to me. It sounds like "I don't buy chairs" like the phrase "I don't drink". I believe people who make it a rule not to buy chairs are unlikely to exist.
は is a particle for emphasis, which turns to mean "topic".
Adding は to other particles such as に、から、emphasize or "topic"alize those particles.
ここにはありません。 (に+は → には)
ここからは行けません。(から+は → からは)
However, when adding は to を/が, it doesn't turn to をは/がは but to は, omitting を/が.
So 椅子を買いません → 椅子をは買いません → 椅子は買いません。
(を+は → は)
椅子は買いません。
1
I checked the page of 椅子は買いません, I think that は is just a programmed answer on the site.
I think that duo**n*o is such an unkind site of learning languages, you can learn many sentences with it, but duo isn't versatile and perfect.
椅子を買いません and 椅子は買いません are correct in grammar, and the meaning is the same.
椅子は買いません。 indicates that the speaker will buy other things, except for chairs, because は Indicates contrast.
Since を is for direct objects, を points 椅子 in 椅子を買いません, not other things, the speaker wants to say "I will not buy chairs".
As you may know, を is called 格助詞/The direct object particle/case particle/object marker, etc.
0
They're both right but I guess it depends on where you want to place the focus.
今日、椅子を買わない. I won't buy a chair today (and you're not going to buy anything else, either)
but 今日、椅子は買わない (as for a/the chair) I won't buy it (but I'm still going to buy other things).
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!
집에서 편안하게 언어를 배울 수 있는 기회를 놓치지 마세요. 경험 많은 강사진을 살펴보고 지금 바로 첫 수업을 신청하세요!
오늘 학습 시작하기
