Dasha
I wish you would do/be or did/were? Please, help me to understand the difference between I wish you would do/be smth and I wish you did/were smth. F.ex. 1. I wish you lived here. vs. I wish you would live here. 2. I wish you listened to me. vs. I wish you would listen to me. 3. I wish you were more attentive. vs. I wish you would be more attentive. Which ones are more preferable or common if any?
2020년 2월 8일 오후 7:22
답변 · 3
1
Carol's choices are the most typical. Here's why: Here, “would” is used with its original meaning from Old English: Would like / would want. You can use it in your examples when you feel that it is a matter of the other person’s will (i.e. willingness). When I say “I wish you would listen”, the implication is that you don’t listen because you refuse to (i.e., don’t want to) listen. It’s definitely a bit more confrontational.
2020년 2월 8일
1
1. I wish you lived here. 2. I wish you would listen to me. 3. I wish you were more attentive. I think that's right and preferable. Let's hear what others have to say If different.
2020년 2월 8일
Phil is right. Knowing what sounds grammatically right and knowing when to use it in conversation comes with a lot of practice. I hope we managed to satisfactorily answer your question. If you'd like to practice speaking, I'd be happy to help you. Feel free to look at my teaching profile and send me a message if you think I can help you.
2020년 2월 8일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!