Alina :)
type III: They _______ (to fly) to Canberra if they______ (to have) more money. I wrote: They would have flown to Canberra if they had more money. Solution: ..... if they had had more money. Whyyyyy :0
2020년 6월 10일 오후 2:05
답변 · 5
1
Because the second "had" is about owning more money and the first "had" is to make a past tense. They would fly to Canberra if they had more money. - Present tense. They would have flown to Canberra if they had had more money. - Past tense. Hopefully a linguist or teacher will be able to give a more technical answer, but that is why.
2020년 6월 10일
They would have flown to Canberra if they had more money. The example is a mix of type 2 and 3. Here are correct type 1, 2, and 3 variations. Type 1 - Real present/future situation If they have enough money, they will fly to Canberra. They will fly to Canberra if they have enough money. [The speaker believes that it is plausible that they will have enough money.] Type 2 - Unreal present/future situation. If they had enough money, they would fly to Canberra. They would fly to Canberra if they had enough money. [The speaker believes that it is implausible that they will have enough money. Here "if they had" is in a past form to indicate an unreal present or future situation. An alternate is "if they were to have" to indicate an unreal present or future situation.] Type 3 - Unreal past situation. If they had had enough money, they would have flown to Canberra. They would have flown to Canberra if they had had enough money. More information here: https://www.ef.com/ca/english-resources/english-grammar/conditional/
2020년 6월 10일
This may sound ridiculous...The second "had" is about money in their wallet. The first "had" is a part of my description of an event that happened last week. Sorry so silly!
2020년 6월 10일
They would have flown to Canberra if they had had more money.
2020년 6월 10일
type 3: If (Past Perfect), (Future in the Past Perfect): If they had had more money, they would have flown to Canberra. (Past Perfect means: had +past participle)
2020년 6월 10일
아직도 답을 찾지 못하셨나요?
질문을 남겨보세요. 원어민이 도움을 줄 수 있을 거예요!